The Gemini Report – Investment Deep Dives

A Comparative Analysis of Nine Insurers: Differentiating Business Models, Performance, and Strategic Outlook

All investment deep dives on this site have been written by Google Gemini with light human editing. Nothing on this site constitutes investment advise. All materials on this site are for informational purposes only.

The Gemini Report - Investment Deep Dives
The Gemini Report – Investment Deep Dives
A Comparative Analysis of Nine Insurers: Differentiating Business Models, Performance, and Strategic Outlook
Loading
/

I. Executive Summary

This report provides a comprehensive comparative analysis of nine distinct firms within the insurance sector: The Travelers Companies (TRV), Primerica (PRI), W. R. Berkley Corporation (WRB), Selective Insurance Group (SIGI), The Chubb Corporation (CB), RLI Corp. (RLI), Progressive Corp. (PGR), Arch Capital Group (ACGL), and Kinsale Capital Group (KNSL). The analysis eschews individual company profiles in favor of a thematic, comparative framework designed to furnish actionable insights for strategic decision-making. The evaluation is structured around four pillars: competitive positioning, financial and underwriting performance, capital management, and strategic outlook.

To facilitate a nuanced comparison, the nine companies have been categorized into five distinct strategic archetypes, each representing a unique approach to risk, distribution, and value creation:

  • The Global Diversified Leaders (TRV, CB): These firms are defined by their immense scale, comprehensive product suites spanning commercial and personal property and casualty (P&C) lines, and extensive global operations. Their competitive moats are built on brand recognition, deep and tenured relationships with agents and brokers, and the financial resilience afforded by broad diversification across geographies and product lines.
  • The Specialty Underwriting Champions (WRB, RLI, ACGL, KNSL): This group thrives by focusing on niche, complex, and hard-to-place risks, primarily within the highly profitable Excess & Surplus (E&S) market. Their success is predicated on superior, specialized underwriting expertise, disciplined risk selection, and operational agility. Within this group, Kinsale stands out for its technology-driven, low-cost operating model that has delivered industry-leading underwriting margins. Arch Capital further diversifies its specialty focus with significant operations in reinsurance and mortgage insurance.
  • The Scale-Driven Personal Lines Innovator (PGR): Progressive represents a unique archetype, having built a dominant position in the U.S. personal auto market through a disruptive direct-to-consumer (DTC) model. Its competitive advantages are rooted in massive and continuous brand investment, sophisticated data analytics, and the pioneering use of telematics for risk pricing.
  • The Super-Regional Main Street Player (SIGI): Selective Insurance Group operates a relationship-intensive model, partnering closely with a network of independent agents to serve commercial and personal clients within specific U.S. regions. Its strategy blends a “high-touch,” field-based underwriting and claims model with modern technology to serve its core customer base.
  • The Middle-Market Distribution Disruptor (PRI): Primerica is a unique entity in this cohort, focusing not on P&C insurance but on providing term life insurance and investment products to middle-income households across North America. Its defining characteristic is its massive, independent sales force, which operates under a multi-level compensation structure, providing unparalleled reach into an often-underserved demographic.

The comparative analysis reveals starkly different performance characteristics across these groups. The E&S specialists, particularly Kinsale and RLI, have consistently delivered superior underwriting profitability, as evidenced by their significantly lower combined ratios and higher returns on equity (ROE). The global leaders, Chubb and Travelers, demonstrate more moderate but highly resilient performance, leveraging their scale to generate substantial and steady capital, which they consistently return to shareholders through dividends and buybacks. Progressive showcases a formidable growth engine, relentlessly gaining market share in personal auto, though its profitability can be subject to the intense pricing dynamics of that market. Selective’s performance reflects the inherent challenges of the standard lines market, including higher catastrophe exposure and recent pressures from social inflation in casualty lines. Primerica’s financial profile is distinct, characterized by stable, high-margin earnings from its in-force life insurance book and strong growth in its investment and savings products division.

Looking forward, each archetype faces a unique set of risks and opportunities. The specialists must navigate the inherent cyclicality of the E&S market. The global leaders must continue to leverage their scale and data analytics to defend their market positions and manage global catastrophe exposures. Progressive’s challenge is to successfully expand its “Destination” strategy beyond auto insurance. Selective must prove it can manage casualty loss trends and achieve its target profitability. Primerica’s success hinges on the continued growth and productivity of its unique sales force. This report deconstructs these strategic positions and performance metrics to provide a clear, data-driven framework for understanding the competitive landscape of the insurance industry.

II. Deconstruction of Business Models and Competitive Positioning

The strategic architecture of an insurance company—its operational scale, chosen markets, and distribution methods—fundamentally dictates its risk profile, growth potential, and financial performance. The nine companies in this analysis represent a broad spectrum of these strategic choices, from highly specialized niche players to globally diversified behemoths.

The Spectrum of Operations: From Niche Specialist to Global Behemoth

The operational scope of the analyzed firms varies dramatically, illustrating fundamentally different philosophies on risk aggregation and diversification. At one end of the spectrum are the global, multi-line giants. Chubb (CB) operates in 54 countries and territories, offering a vast portfolio of commercial P&C, personal P&C, accident and health, reinsurance, and life insurance products.1 Similarly, The Travelers Companies (TRV) is a leading U.S. P&C insurer with significant international operations, providing coverage for auto, home, and business customers through a diverse set of business lines.3 These firms pursue a strategy of broad diversification across products and geographies, which provides stability and resilience against localized or segment-specific downturns. Their scale allows them to absorb large catastrophe losses more readily and serve as a comprehensive risk partner for large multinational corporations, a market inaccessible to smaller, more focused carriers.

Occupying a middle ground are hybrid specialists like Arch Capital Group (ACGL) and W. R. Berkley Corporation (WRB). Both operate globally but with a distinct focus on specialty insurance and reinsurance lines. Arch further diversifies its platform with a substantial mortgage insurance segment, providing risk management and financing products to the housing sector worldwide.4 W. R. Berkley operates through a decentralized structure of nearly 60 distinct business units, each focused on a niche market requiring specialized knowledge of a particular territory or product.7 This model grants them the agility to respond to local market conditions while backed by the resources of a Fortune 500 company.

At the other end of the spectrum are the focused specialists. Kinsale Capital Group (KNSL) is a pure-play U.S. insurer focused exclusively on the excess and surplus (E&S) market, underwriting hard-to-place risks for small and mid-sized businesses.10 RLI Corp. (RLI) similarly concentrates on underserved niche property, casualty, and surety markets within the United States.13 The strategic thesis for these specialists is that deep expertise in uncorrelated, difficult-to-price niches allows them to generate superior underwriting returns (alpha). Their narrow focus facilitates unparalleled underwriting expertise and pricing power in markets with less competition, which is their primary driver of value.

The remaining firms occupy unique positions. Progressive (PGR) is a domestic giant but is overwhelmingly concentrated in personal and commercial auto insurance, where it is a market leader.15 Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) defines its strategy as a “super-regional” carrier, focusing on standard commercial and personal lines in 35 U.S. states, primarily in the eastern and midwestern regions.16 Finally, Primerica (PRI) stands as a complete outlier in this cohort. It does not operate in the P&C space; instead, it is a leading provider of term life insurance and investment products, such as mutual funds and annuities, to middle-income households in the U.S. and Canada.19

This divergence in business models represents a direct trade-off between the pursuit of high, specialized underwriting margins, characteristic of the E&S players, and the pursuit of stability, scale, and enterprise-level client relationships that defines the diversified global leaders. This strategic choice is the most critical factor explaining the profound differences in their financial performance, risk profiles, and market valuations.

Distribution Strategy as a Moat: Agents vs. Direct vs. Armies

The method by which an insurer reaches its customers is a core component of its competitive strategy, defining its cost structure, customer relationships, and growth levers.

The traditional independent agent and broker channel remains the dominant model for the majority of the companies analyzed, particularly in commercial and specialty lines. Travelers, Chubb, W. R. Berkley, RLI, Arch Capital, and Kinsale all rely primarily on this network of third-party professionals to distribute their products.3 Success in this channel is predicated on cultivating deep, long-term relationships, providing superior service and claims handling, and offering competitive compensation. Selective Insurance Group has explicitly built its entire business around this concept, terming it a “franchise value distribution model” that emphasizes a “high-touch” approach with empowered, field-based employees working directly with a select group of high-quality agency partners.18 For these carriers, their “moat” is the stickiness of these relationships, which can be slower to build but provides a resilient flow of high-quality business that is less susceptible to pure price competition.

In stark contrast, Progressive has pioneered the direct-to-consumer (DTC) model in the U.S. personal auto market. While it also maintains a strong agency channel, its competitive identity is defined by its direct business, which is written online or over the phone.24 This model is fueled by a massive and highly sophisticated marketing engine, with the company investing billions annually in advertising to build one of the most recognizable brands in the industry.25 The DTC approach provides Progressive with a direct relationship with its customers, eliminating agent commissions and generating a vast trove of data that informs its underwriting and pricing models. This strategy is capital-intensive from a marketing perspective but allows for rapid scaling and customer acquisition, making its growth a direct function of its marketing efficiency and technological prowess.

Primerica operates with a third, entirely unique model: a multi-level independent sales force. The company distributes its term life insurance and investment products through a force of over 152,000 licensed representatives who are independent contractors.21 These representatives are compensated not only for their own sales but also for sales made by other representatives they recruit into their “downline”.21 This model effectively externalizes the costs of recruitment, training, and sales to the representatives themselves, creating significant operating leverage for the parent company. It provides unparalleled, grassroots-level access to its target middle-income market, a demographic often underserved by traditional financial advisors. This people-intensive model scales through network effects, making Primerica’s growth fundamentally dependent on its ability to recruit, motivate, and retain its vast sales army.

These distinct distribution choices create structural differences in operating expenses and strategic imperatives. Progressive’s success is tied to its brand equity and cost-per-acquisition. Primerica’s fortunes are linked to the growth and productivity of its human capital network. The agent-based carriers’ success depends on their ability to be the preferred partner for the best independent agents and brokers in their chosen markets.

Table 1: Company Profile and Business Model Matrix

Company (Ticker)Primary Business FocusPrimary Distribution Channel(s)Geographic FootprintKey Target Market(s)
The Travelers Companies, Inc. (TRV)Global P&C (Commercial, Personal, Specialty)Independent Agents & BrokersU.S., Canada, UK, Ireland 3Businesses, government units, individuals 29
Primerica, Inc. (PRI)Term Life Insurance & Investment ProductsIndependent Sales Force (Multi-Level)U.S., Canada, Puerto Rico, Guam 20Middle-income households 19
W. R. Berkley Corporation (WRB)Specialty P&C (Insurance & Reinsurance)Independent Agents & BrokersWorldwide (U.S., Europe, Asia, Australia) 9Niche commercial and high-net-worth personal lines 7
Selective Insurance Group Inc. (SIGI)Super-Regional P&C (Commercial & Personal)Independent AgentsPrimarily Eastern & Midwestern U.S. (35 states) 17Small-to-medium commercial enterprises, mass affluent individuals 18
The Chubb Corporation (CB)Global P&C, A&H, Reinsurance, LifeIndependent Agents & BrokersWorldwide (operations in 54 countries) 1Large corporations, middle market, high-net-worth individuals 32
RLI Corp. (RLI)Specialty P&C (Casualty, Property, Surety)Independent Agents & BrokersUnited States 13Niche, hard-to-place commercial and personal risks 14
Progressive Corp. (PGR)Personal & Commercial Auto InsuranceDirect-to-Consumer (DTC) & Independent AgentsUnited States 15Broad range of personal and commercial auto consumers 15
Arch Capital Group Ltd. (ACGL)Specialty P&C (Insurance, Reinsurance, Mortgage)Brokers & Ceding CompaniesWorldwide (Bermuda-based) 4Specialty lines, mortgage lenders, other insurers 6
Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. (KNSL)Specialty Excess & Surplus (E&S) InsuranceSelect Independent BrokersUnited States 11Hard-to-place small and mid-sized business risks 10

III. Comparative Financial and Underwriting Performance

A rigorous examination of historical financial data reveals the tangible outcomes of the divergent strategies employed by the nine insurers. Key metrics such as premium growth, underwriting profitability, and returns on capital serve as a scorecard, highlighting a clear bifurcation in performance between the agile specialists and the scaled incumbents.

Top-Line Growth Dynamics

Over the past five years, the cohort has experienced varied growth trajectories, largely reflecting their respective market positioning and the cyclicality of their chosen segments. The E&S specialists have been the standout performers, capitalizing on a “hard” market characterized by rising premium rates and reduced capacity from standard carriers. Kinsale has delivered explosive growth, with annual revenue increasing by 29.7% in 2024, 46.0% in 2023, and 28.4% in 2022.34 This exceptional expansion is a function of both favorable pricing and strong submission flow from brokers for hard-to-place risks.35 Arch Capital has also posted robust growth, with net premiums written in its insurance segment increasing 17% in 2024, aided by organic opportunities and the acquisition of Allianz’s U.S. MidCorp business.36

Progressive has demonstrated its prowess as a market-share-gaining machine in the massive personal auto space. Its annual revenue grew by 21.4% in 2024 and 25.2% in 2023, driven by its powerful brand and competitive pricing advantages.38

The larger, more mature global leaders have posted more moderate but still substantial growth. Travelers grew net written premiums by 8% in 2024 to a record $43.4 billion, marking its 15th consecutive year of top-line expansion.39 Chubb’s Global P&C premiums grew by nearly 10% in 2024, reflecting its broad global footprint and diversified portfolio.40

This bifurcation in growth rates is a direct reflection of the law of large numbers for the incumbents and the powerful tailwinds benefiting the specialists and market disruptors. The sustainability of these trends is a key strategic question: the specialists’ growth is partly cyclical and dependent on the continuation of favorable E&S market conditions, whereas Progressive’s growth appears more structural, and the global leaders’ growth is more closely tied to broad economic activity and P&C pricing cycles.

Underwriting Profitability Deep Dive: The Combined Ratio Divide

The combined ratio, which measures total underwriting expenses as a percentage of net earned premiums, is the purest indicator of an insurer’s underwriting discipline and profitability. A ratio below 100% signifies an underwriting profit. On this metric, the E&S specialists have established a clear and consistent performance advantage.

Kinsale stands in a class of its own, consistently posting industry-leading combined ratios. For the full year 2024, its combined ratio was an exceptionally low 76.4%, following a 75.4% result in 2023.10 This remarkable profitability is a direct result of its proprietary technology platform, which enables a highly efficient, low-cost operating model (expense ratio of 20.8% in 2024), and its disciplined underwriting of high-premium, hard-to-place risks where it has significant pricing power (loss ratio of 55.8% in 2024).11 RLI Corp. also boasts a stellar long-term record, achieving its 29th consecutive year of underwriting profitability in 2024 with a combined ratio of 86.2%.41

The larger, diversified carriers exhibit higher and more volatile combined ratios, primarily due to their greater exposure to natural catastrophes and the more competitive nature of standard insurance lines. Selective Insurance Group’s 2024 combined ratio was 103.0%, reflecting 6.5 points of catastrophe losses and 7.1 points of unfavorable prior year casualty reserve development, which indicates pressure from social inflation.43 Travelers and Chubb, while generally profitable, also show the impact of their catastrophe exposure. For Q2 2025, Travelers reported a combined ratio of 90.3%, a significant improvement from the prior year due to lower catastrophe losses.44 Chubb posted a strong 85.6% combined ratio in the same quarter, demonstrating its disciplined underwriting across its global platform.1 Progressive’s combined ratio is subject to the intense competition and loss cost trends of the auto insurance market; its five-year average combined ratio has consistently outperformed the private passenger auto composite, showcasing its underwriting acumen.45

The significant gap in underwriting profitability between the specialists and the standard lines carriers is a direct reflection of their business models. The specialists benefit from the pricing freedom of the unregulated E&S market and a focus on risks where expertise, not price, is the primary determinant. The standard lines carriers must contend with rate regulation, intense price competition, and the inherent volatility of catastrophe-exposed property lines.

Profitability and Returns on Capital

Return on Equity (ROE) synthesizes underwriting and investment performance with balance sheet leverage to measure a company’s efficiency in generating profits for shareholders. Here again, the performance of the cohort diverges, driven by the unique attributes of each business model.

In 2024, the specialty players delivered outstanding returns. Kinsale led the group with an ROE of 32.3% 10, and W. R. Berkley posted a strong 23.6% ROE.46 These exceptional results are primarily driven by their high levels of underwriting income.

Primerica also generates a very high ROE, reporting 33% in Q2 2025, but through a different mechanism.47 Its capital-light distribution model, where sales costs are largely variable, combined with stable and predictable earnings from its large in-force book of term life policies, produces high returns on a comparatively smaller equity base.

The global leaders produced solid returns, with Travelers reporting a core ROE of 17.2% and Chubb reporting a core operating ROE of 13.9% for 2024.48 Their returns, while lower than the top-performing specialists, are generated on a much larger capital base and demonstrate the powerful, albeit more moderate, earnings generation of their diversified franchises. At the lower end for 2024, Selective’s non-GAAP operating ROE was 7.1%, weighed down by the underwriting challenges that pushed its combined ratio above 100%.16

The market consistently rewards companies that can sustainably generate high ROEs with premium valuation multiples. The significant disparity in ROE across this group is a primary driver of the wide divergence in their market valuations.

Investment Income and Portfolio Strategy

Investment income generated from policyholder premiums, or “float,” is a critical component of an insurer’s earnings. The strategies employed by the cohort generally reflect a conservative, capital preservation-focused approach, with portfolios heavily weighted toward high-quality fixed-income securities.

Travelers, for instance, holds 94% of its $94.2 billion investment portfolio in fixed income assets, with 98.8% of those holdings rated investment grade.50 This conservative posture is designed to ensure the company can meet its policyholder obligations under almost any foreseeable circumstance. In 2024, this portfolio generated a strong $3.0 billion in after-tax net investment income.51 Similarly, RLI targets an allocation of 80% bonds and 20% equities, with its fixed-income portfolio maintaining an average quality rating of ‘AA-‘.52

While the overall philosophy is conservative, there are differences in execution. W. R. Berkley complements its high-quality, short-duration bond portfolio with investments in common stocks, merger arbitrage, private equity, and commercial real estate, which have been accretive to its overall ROE over time.53 Arch Capital also emphasizes a total-return approach, with its 2020 portfolio generating a total return of 7.77%.54

The rising interest rate environment of recent years has been a significant tailwind for the entire sector. As older, lower-yielding bonds mature, companies are able to reinvest the proceeds at higher rates, leading to steady growth in net investment income. Travelers, for example, expects its fixed-income portfolio alone to generate approximately $3 billion in after-tax income in 2025.39 This reliable and growing stream of investment income provides a crucial earnings buffer, particularly for companies with higher underwriting volatility.

Table 2: Historical Financial Performance (2019-2024)

(All figures in millions of USD, except per-share data and ratios)

Company (Ticker)YearTotal RevenueNet Premiums WrittenNet IncomeReturn on Equity (ROE) (%)GAAP Combined Ratio (%)Book Value per Share ($)
TRV202446,42343,4004,99919.296.5 (est.)122.97
202341,36440,2002,99113.697.5109.19
202236,88435,4002,84212.295.692.90
202134,81631,9003,66212.796.6119.77
202031,98129,7002,69710.094.7115.68
201931,58129,1512,62210.596.5101.55
PRI20243,0891,84347131.2 (adj.)N/A67.70
20232,7491,72057727.2 (adj.)N/A59.04
20222,6571,60755725.4 (adj.)N/A49.37
20212,6491,46542724.3 (adj.)N/A46.54
20202,2181,31038624.7 (adj.)N/A46.71
20192,0531,16736623.5 (adj.)N/A40.10
WRB202413,63911,9721,75623.690.335.49
202312,14310,9541,38120.590.428.74
202211,3999,8131,12016.992.125.10
20219,8488,4601,02916.291.825.19
20208,1007,2005928.794.922.95
20197,9006,90072412.593.820.21
SIGI20244,8624,6301987.0103.047.99
20234,2324,13535614.396.545.42
20223,5583,3812778.895.441.74
20213,3813,09936813.991.446.40
20202,9222,77324610.494.942.38
20192,8472,67927213.693.736.91
CB202462,00351,4689,27215.086.6159.77
202350,29045,9589,03015.786.5143.20
202241,01038,1574,5507.894.0134.19
202138,87035,4688,54014.490.3136.20
202041,26133,8203,5336.296.1131.88
201940,12432,2754,4548.490.6122.42
RLI20241,7701,60634622.286.216.59
20231,5121,42830523.386.615.49
20221,7001,20029026.285.313.56
20211,1801,00014214.594.014.28
2020980830808.791.813.50
20191,0007709613.491.911.09
PGR202475,37274,4008,48035.592.943.69
202362,10961,6003,90322.997.733.80
202249,61151,1007224.495.726.32
202147,70246,4003,35018.696.130.35
202042,65840,6005,70535.687.828.27
201939,02237,9003,97024.791.117.71
ACGL202417,44015,7004,27222.984.753.11
202313,63413,5004,40029.581.946.10
20229,6138,1701,84012.888.935.94
20219,2487,7001,72013.290.933.68
20208,5097,4001,36411.894.630.31
20196,9266,0401,59516.583.726.42
KNSL20241,5881,87041532.376.463.75
20231,2241,56930833.675.446.88
20228391,10215922.078.532.28
202165376415323.977.630.63
20204605538818.086.725.32
20193163906316.784.722.42
Note: Data compiled from multiple sources including annual reports, financial supplements, and data aggregators. ROE and Combined Ratio may be based on reported or operating figures depending on company disclosure. Primerica’s Net Premiums Written reflects Term Life segment only. Some figures are estimated based on reported growth rates.10

IV. Capital Management and Balance Sheet Resilience

An insurer’s approach to capital management and the underlying strength of its balance sheet are critical determinants of its long-term viability and ability to create shareholder value. A strong capital position enables a company to underwrite new business, withstand unexpected losses, and return capital to shareholders.

Capital Allocation Philosophies

The cohort displays a range of capital allocation strategies, from steadfast dividend growth to more opportunistic share repurchases. RLI Corp. and Chubb stand out as “dividend champions.” RLI has increased its regular dividend for 50 consecutive years, a testament to its consistent underwriting profitability and conservative management philosophy.85 Chubb boasts a similar track record, having approved its 32nd consecutive annual dividend increase in 2025.1 For these firms, the dividend is a core component of their shareholder value proposition, signaling a commitment to predictable capital generation and attracting a stable, income-oriented investor base. This policy implies a high degree of management confidence in their long-term earnings power and creates a powerful incentive to maintain underwriting discipline to support the growing payout.

Other firms employ a more flexible, total-return approach that heavily features share repurchases. Primerica, for instance, returned $163 million to shareholders in Q2 2025, with $129 million (79%) allocated to buybacks and $34 million to dividends.88 This indicates a management belief that reinvesting in the company’s own shares at current prices is a highly accretive use of capital. W. R. Berkley also utilizes a dynamic approach, frequently supplementing its regular dividend with special dividends and share repurchases. In Q2 2025, the company returned $224 million to shareholders, of which $190 million was a special dividend.78 This opportunistic strategy provides more flexibility than a rigid dividend policy, allowing management to adjust capital returns based on market conditions and their assessment of the stock’s intrinsic value.

Financial Leverage and Creditworthiness

The financial strength of an insurer is externally validated by credit rating agencies, which assess its ability to meet policyholder obligations. There is a clear correlation between an insurer’s scale, diversification, and its credit rating. The global diversified leaders, Travelers and Chubb, hold the highest possible Financial Strength Rating (FSR) from AM Best of A++ (Superior).90 The rating agency’s rationale for Travelers explicitly cites its “broad spread of risk” and diversified portfolio as key strengths, highlighting the “shock absorber” effect that diversification provides against severe stress events.90

The specialty carriers, while exhibiting excellent financial performance, generally hold ratings one notch below the giants. W. R. Berkley, RLI, and Arch Capital all have strong A+ (Superior) FSRs from AM Best.92 Kinsale holds an A (Excellent) FSR, with AM Best noting its strong operating performance but “neutral” business profile, an acknowledgment of its concentration in the E&S market.95 These ratings recognize the specialists’ superior underwriting but implicitly account for the higher theoretical risk associated with their more concentrated business models. Selective Insurance Group also holds an A+ (Superior) rating, while Primerica’s life insurance subsidiaries are rated A+ (Superior), reflecting their strong capitalization and consistent profitability.96

The Litmus Test of Reserving

An insurer’s reserving practices are a crucial indicator of its underwriting conservatism and the quality of its earnings. Consistently releasing reserves from prior accident years (favorable development) suggests that initial loss estimates were prudent. Conversely, needing to strengthen reserves for prior years (adverse development) can signal that past underwriting was inadequately priced and can negatively impact current earnings.

Selective Insurance Group has recently faced challenges in this area. In Q4 2024, the company recorded $100 million of net unfavorable prior year casualty reserve development, which added 8.8 points to its combined ratio.56 It took another $45 million charge in Q2 2025.98 Management attributes these actions to the impact of “social inflation” on general liability and commercial auto claims, an industry-wide trend of rising litigation costs and jury awards. While SIGI notes that its historical reserving has been more responsive than the industry average, these recent charges have weighed on its profitability.98 In contrast, firms like RLI and Travelers have consistently reported favorable prior year reserve development, which has provided a tailwind to their underwriting results. In Q2 2025, Travelers reported $315 million in favorable development, while RLI reported a $24.4 million net increase to underwriting income from the same source.44 This consistent favorable development is a hallmark of a disciplined and conservative underwriting culture.

Table 3: Balance Sheet and Credit Rating Summary (as of most recent available data)

Company (Ticker)Total Assets ($B)Shareholders’ Equity ($B)Debt-to-Capital Ratio (%)AM Best FSRS&P RatingMoody’s Rating
TRV133.227.922.1 (est.)A++AAAa2
PRI14.9 (2020)1.8 (2020)16.9 (2020)A+A-A1 (IFS)
WRB47.49.323.4A+A+A2 (IFS)
SIGI9.7 (2024)2.7 (2020)19.2 (2024)A+AA2 (IFS)
CB261.669.424.5 (est.)A++AAAa3 (IFS)
RLI5.61.510.5 (est.)A+A+A1 (IFS)
PGR105.725.621.0 (est.)A+AAAa2 (IFS)
ACGL70.923.514.8 (est.)A+A+A2 (IFS)
KNSL5.41.79.7AN/AN/A
Note: Data compiled from multiple sources and reporting periods. Debt-to-Capital ratios are estimates based on available data and may differ from company-reported figures. Credit ratings refer to the primary operating subsidiaries’ Financial Strength Rating (FSR) or equivalent Insurance Financial Strength (IFS) rating.1

V. Relative Valuation Framework

Market valuation multiples provide a lens through which to view investor perception of a company’s growth prospects, profitability, and risk profile. The analysis of Price-to-Earnings (P/E) and Price-to-Book Value (P/B) ratios for this cohort reveals a clear segmentation by the market, which awards premium valuations to companies with superior growth and profitability metrics.

Peer Valuation Matrix and Interpretation

The market assigns a distinct premium to the high-growth, high-ROE specialty insurers, particularly Kinsale. While a precise P/B ratio requires real-time data, KNSL’s consistent combination of 30%+ ROE and 30%+ revenue growth justifies a P/B multiple that is significantly higher than its peers. This premium valuation reflects investor confidence in the sustainability of its technology-driven underwriting advantage and its long runway for growth within the fragmented E&S market. The market is effectively paying a premium for a best-in-class operator that has demonstrated a rare ability to grow rapidly while maintaining exceptional underwriting discipline.

Progressive also commands a premium valuation relative to most traditional P&C carriers. This is attributable to its consistent track record of above-average growth, strong brand recognition, and a business model that is perceived as having a durable competitive advantage in data and analytics. Investors are willing to pay a higher multiple for its proven ability to profitably take market share in the vast U.S. auto insurance market.

In contrast, the large, mature global leaders like Travelers and Chubb, along with regional players like Selective, tend to trade at more modest, value-oriented multiples. Their lower P/B ratios reflect their lower (though still strong) ROEs and more moderate growth profiles. For these companies, the investment thesis is less about hyper-growth and more about stability, diversification, and the consistent generation of excess capital that is returned to shareholders through dividends and buybacks. Their valuation reflects their status as reliable, blue-chip compounders rather than high-growth disruptors.

Primerica presents an interesting case with a P/E ratio noted at an attractive 11.86.47 This relatively low multiple, especially when compared to its high reported ROE, suggests that the market may have reservations about its unique multi-level distribution model or may be underappreciating the stability and cash-generative nature of its in-force term life business.

Ultimately, the valuation spectrum within this cohort encapsulates the fundamental trade-off facing investors: “growth at a premium price” versus “value and stability.” An investor’s preference depends on their conviction in the long-term sustainability of the specialists’ high margins, their outlook for the intensely competitive personal lines market, or their preference for the steady, diversified earnings power of the global leaders.

Table 4: Comparative Valuation Multiples (as of late August 2025)

Company (Ticker)Market Capitalization ($B)Price-to-Earnings (P/E) (TTM)Price-to-Book (P/B) (MRQ)
TRV59.512.12.2
PRI9.011.94.0
WRB27.617.63.0
SIGI4.812.81.5
CB111.212.91.7
RLI6.324.23.6
PGR145.914.55.7
ACGL34.211.21.5
KNSL10.523.66.1
Note: Market data is approximate and subject to change. P/E and P/B ratios are based on trailing twelve months earnings and most recent quarter’s book value, respectively. Some figures are derived from multiple sources and may vary.4

VI. Synthesis of Risks and Strategic Outlook

While the insurance industry offers opportunities for profitable growth and capital generation, it is fraught with a diverse set of risks. The nature and severity of these risks vary significantly across the different business models represented in this analysis. A forward-looking assessment requires understanding these distinct risk profiles and the strategic initiatives each company is deploying to mitigate them.

Comparative Risk Exposures

The risk profiles of the nine companies are as distinct as their business models, meaning an investment in the sector is not a monolithic bet but rather a specific wager on a company’s ability to manage a particular set of challenges.

  • Catastrophe Risk: This is the most significant and volatile risk for insurers with substantial property exposure. The financial results of Travelers, Chubb, and Selective are heavily influenced by the frequency and severity of natural disasters like hurricanes, wildfires, and convective storms. In Q1 2025, Travelers’ results were materially impacted by $2.27 billion in pre-tax catastrophe losses, primarily from California wildfires, which added 21.2 points to its combined ratio.123 The strategic challenge for these firms is to use sophisticated modeling, disciplined underwriting, and reinsurance to manage this exposure and price it adequately over the long term.
  • Social Inflation and Reserve Risk: This risk is most acute for carriers with significant exposure to long-tail casualty lines, such as general liability and commercial auto. “Social inflation” refers to the trend of rising litigation costs, broader definitions of liability, and larger jury awards, which can cause losses for claims from prior years to develop beyond original expectations. Selective’s recent performance has been impacted by this trend, forcing it to take significant unfavorable prior year reserve development charges in 2024 and 2025, which directly reduced earnings.56 W. R. Berkley has also highlighted social inflation as a key concern.33 Managing this risk requires conservative initial loss picks, disciplined pricing to account for future loss trends, and expert claims management.
  • Competitive and Cyclical Risk: The entire P&C industry is cyclical, with periods of intense price competition (“soft” markets) followed by periods of rising prices and stricter underwriting (“hard” markets). The E&S specialists (KNSL, RLI, WRB, ACGL) have been major beneficiaries of the recent hard market, but they face the risk that an influx of new capital could lead to a market softening, which would pressure their growth rates and margins.33 Progressive faces a different form of competitive risk: a perpetual battle for market share in the highly transparent and price-sensitive personal auto market, where large advertising budgets and sophisticated pricing algorithms are table stakes.
  • Distribution Model Risk: Primerica’s unique business model carries a unique risk. Its growth is fundamentally contingent on its ability to recruit, train, and motivate its massive independent sales force.47 A significant decline in recruitment or an increase in agent turnover could directly impede its ability to sell new policies and gather assets, presenting a headwind to growth.

Divergent Paths Forward: The Strategic Theses

The future success of each company will be determined by its ability to execute a strategy that reinforces its core competitive advantages and navigates its specific risk profile. There is no single “best” strategy, but rather a set of distinct strategic questions that define the forward-looking thesis for each archetype.

  • The Global Diversified Leaders (TRV, CB): The core thesis is that their immense scale, diversification, and data advantages will allow them to generate stable, through-the-cycle returns and continue to produce capital in excess of their growth needs. Their path forward involves leveraging advanced analytics to refine underwriting and pricing, enhancing digital tools for agents and customers, and maintaining their disciplined approach to capital returns through steadily growing dividends and share repurchases.48 The key question is whether they can deploy their advantages effectively enough to achieve their target mid-teens ROEs consistently, even in the face of significant catastrophe volatility.
  • The Specialty Underwriting Champions (WRB, RLI, ACGL, KNSL): The thesis for this group is that their deep expertise in niche markets will allow them to continue generating superior underwriting margins. Their strategy is to remain disciplined, walking away from underpriced business during soft markets and aggressively capitalizing on opportunities during hard markets.10 For Kinsale, the strategy also involves leveraging its proprietary technology platform to maintain its industry-leading expense advantage. The central question for this group is whether they can defend their high margins and returns as the E&S market cycle inevitably turns and competition intensifies.
  • The Scale-Driven Personal Lines Innovator (PGR): Progressive’s forward-looking thesis is its “Destination Era” strategy, which aims to leverage its dominant position in auto insurance to become a broader provider of other products, most notably homeowners insurance.15 By bundling policies and deepening customer relationships, the company seeks to increase customer lifetime value and build an even stickier franchise. The key question is whether Progressive can successfully translate its brand and data advantages from the auto market into the structurally different homeowners market, where catastrophe risk plays a much larger role.
  • The Super-Regional Main Street Player (SIGI): Selective’s path forward is focused on achieving its target profitability by balancing disciplined growth with its relationship-based agency model. The strategy involves continued geographic expansion into new states, investing in technology to improve the agent and customer experience, and taking decisive underwriting and pricing actions to address the challenges of social inflation in its casualty lines.43 The critical question is whether these actions will be sufficient to bring its combined ratio back to its long-term target and generate consistent, double-digit operating ROEs.
  • The Middle-Market Distribution Disruptor (PRI): Primerica’s strategic thesis is centered on the continued growth of its sales force to further penetrate the vast and underserved middle-income market in North America.126 The company aims to leverage its distribution scale to grow its high-margin term life business and increase sales of investment and savings products. The key question is whether its unique, face-to-face distribution model can continue to thrive and attract new representatives in an increasingly digital world.

The analysis concludes not with a singular recommendation, but with a clear articulation of these central strategic questions. This framework provides the necessary context for an investor to make an informed decision based on their own view of the future of the insurance market and their confidence in each management team’s ability to execute its distinct strategy.

Works cited

  1. Chubb Limited – Investor Relations, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investors.chubb.com/home/default.aspx
  2. Chubb Commercial Insurance, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.chubb.com/content/dam/chubb-sites/chubb-com/ca-en/individuals-families/broker-partner-services/2017-12-13-commercial-insurance-overview.pdf
  3. Travelers Investor Relations | Home, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investor.travelers.com/home/default.aspx
  4. ACGL Investor Relations – Arch Capital Group Ltd – Alpha Spread, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.alphaspread.com/security/nasdaq/acgl/investor-relations
  5. Arch Capital Group Ltd. – Specialty Insurance Company, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.archgroup.com/
  6. Arch Capital Group Ltd. – Investor Relations, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ir.archgroup.com/overview/default.aspx
  7. W. R. Berkley Corporation, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.berkley.com/
  8. W.R. Berkley Corp – AnnualReports.com, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/Company/wr-berkley-corp
  9. wrb-20241231 – SEC.gov, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/11544/000001154425000005/wrb-20241231.htm
  10. Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. | Investor Relations, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ir.kinsalecapitalgroup.com/overview/default.aspx
  11. Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. | Specialty Insurance Group, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.kinsalecapitalgroup.com/
  12. KINSALE CAPITAL GROUP, INC., accessed August 30, 2025, https://s29.q4cdn.com/479990906/files/doc_financials/2024/q4/add4c110-7959-4f78-96c1-fbf0ab590ca9.pdf
  13. RLI Corp. – AnnualReports.com, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/Company/rli-corp
  14. RLI CORP., accessed August 30, 2025, https://s204.q4cdn.com/949661285/files/doc_financials/2024/q4/01171a60-4ebd-4a75-9b9e-98c880633730.pdf
  15. Investor Relations | Progressive, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investors.progressive.com/home/default.aspx
  16. Investor Information | Invest in Selective Insurance Group, Inc., accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.selective.com/investors
  17. Selective at a Glance | Selective Insurance, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.selective.com/about-selective/at-a-glance
  18. Selective Insurance Group, Inc. – 10K – Annual Report – February 09, 2024 – Fintel, accessed August 30, 2025, https://fintel.io/doc/sec-selective-insurance-group-inc-230557-10k-2024-february-09-19762-1742
  19. PFS Investments | Primerica Financial Services, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.primerica.com/public/primerica-investments.html
  20. About Primerica – What is Primerica and What Does It Do?, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.primerica.com/public/about-primerica.html
  21. Annual Report for Fiscal Year Ending December 31, 2024 (Form 10-K) – Public now, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.publicnow.com/view/9A2F70377F0858D5CF827AAB7B4ACF8E9F491F61?1740779255
  22. Chubb North America Major Accounts, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.chubb.com/content/dam/chubb-sites/chubb-com/ca-en/individuals-families/broker-partner-services/2017-12-13-major-accounts-overview.pdf
  23. Selective Insurance Agent Compensation, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.selective.com/site-services/agent-compensation
  24. THE PROGRESSIVE CORPORATION, accessed August 30, 2025, https://s202.q4cdn.com/605347829/files/doc_financials/2024/q4/2f9b6d44-973f-48b8-aa92-190dbd0b6c56.pdf
  25. 2024 Annual Report to Shareholders, accessed August 30, 2025, https://s202.q4cdn.com/605347829/files/doc_financials/2024/q4/interactive/pdfs/Progressive-2024-Financial-Review.pdf
  26. Primerica, Inc. (PRI), accessed August 30, 2025, https://investors.primerica.com/
  27. accessed December 31, 1969, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1475922/000095017025021417/pri-20241231.htm
  28. Complete Marketing Strategy Of Travelers – 2025 | IIDE, accessed August 30, 2025, https://iide.co/case-studies/marketing-strategy-of-travelers/
  29. The Travelers Companies, Inc. – AnnualReports.com, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/Company/the-travelers-companies-inc
  30. Primerica Contact, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.primerica.com/public/contact.html
  31. Selective Insurance Group – AnnualReports.com, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/Company/selective-insurance-group
  32. Chubb Limited (via Public) / Annual Report for Fiscal Year Ending …, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.publicnow.com/view/F82199F7FC47382FDE958C8DF8C27262FFD604BE?1740692811
  33. RLI Corp. (RLI) Stock Price, Market Cap, Segmented Revenue & Earnings – Datainsightsmarket.com, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.datainsightsmarket.com/companies/RLI
  34. Kinsale Capital Revenue 2014-2025 | KNSL – Macrotrends, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/KNSL/kinsale-capital/revenue
  35. Financials – Quarterly Results – Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. | Investor Relations, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ir.kinsalecapitalgroup.com/financials/quarterly-results/default.aspx
  36. 2024ANNUAL REPORT – SEC.gov, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/947484/000094748425000033/annual-reportx10k.pdf
  37. Financials – Quarterly Results – Arch Capital Group Ltd. – Investor Relations, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ir.archgroup.com/financials/quarterly-results/default.aspx
  38. Progressive Revenue 2010-2025 | PGR | MacroTrends, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/PGR/progressive/revenue
  39. Travelers 2024 Annual Report, accessed August 30, 2025, https://s26.q4cdn.com/410417801/files/doc_financials/oar/travelersAR2024/index.html
  40. Chubb Limited 2024 Annual Report Letter to Shareholders, accessed August 30, 2025, https://about.chubb.com/stories/2024-shareholder-letter.html
  41. RLI Reports Fourth Quarter and Year-End 2024 Results, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investors.rlicorp.com/news/news-details/2025/RLI-Reports-Fourth-Quarter-and-Year-End-2024-Results/default.aspx
  42. RLI CORP. ANNUAL REPORT ON FORM 10K, accessed August 30, 2025, https://s204.q4cdn.com/949661285/files/doc_financials/2024/ar/RLI-2024-ARS-Final.pdf
  43. 2024 Annual Report – Selective Insurance, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.selective.com/~/media/Files/S/Selective-V2/reports-presentations/reports/sigi-2024-annual-report.pdf
  44. Travelers Q2 2025 presentation slides: Net income surges 183%, all segments profitable, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.investing.com/news/company-news/travelers-q2-2025-presentation-slides-net-income-surges-183-all-segments-profitable-93CH-4139376
  45. AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of The Progressive Corporation and Its Subsidiaries, accessed August 30, 2025, https://news.ambest.com/newscontent.aspx?refnum=256518&altsrc=176
  46. W. R. Berkley Corporation Reports Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2024 Results, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ir.berkley.com/news/news-details/2025/W.-R.-Berkley-Corporation-Reports-Fourth-Quarter-and-Full-Year-2024-Results/default.aspx
  47. Earnings call transcript: Primerica Q2 2025 sees earnings beat but stock dips, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.investing.com/news/transcripts/earnings-call-transcript-primerica-q2-2025-sees-earnings-beat-but-stock-dips-93CH-4178082
  48. Financial Performance – Travelers Sustainability Report, accessed August 30, 2025, https://sustainability.travelers.com/financial-performance
  49. Chubb Limited Annual Report 2024, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.chubb.com/content/dam/annual-corporate-governance/2025/a–chubb-limited/chubb-limited-annual-report-2024.pdf
  50. Investment Management – Travelers Sustainability Report, accessed August 30, 2025, https://sustainability.travelers.com/company/investment-management
  51. Financial Performance: 2024 Results | Travelers Sustainability Report, accessed August 30, 2025, https://sustainability.travelers.com/financial-performance/results
  52. RLI Q2 2025 presentation: EPS beat, revenue miss amid underwriting challenges, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.investing.com/news/company-news/rli-q2-2025-presentation-eps-beat-revenue-miss-amid-underwriting-challenges-93CH-4194674
  53. W. R. Berkley Corporation – AnnualReports.com, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/w/NYSE_WRB_2019.pdf
  54. Arch Capital Group Ltd. 2020 Annual Report – AnnualReports.com, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/a/NASDAQ_ACGL_2020.pdf
  55. W. R. Berkley Corporation Reports Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2024 Results, accessed August 30, 2025, https://s29.q4cdn.com/304856890/files/doc_news/W.-R.-Berkley-Corporation-Reports-Fourth-Quarter-and-Full-Year-2024-Results-2025.pdf
  56. Selective Reports Fourth Quarter and Year-End 2024 Results, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.selective.com/investors/news-and-filings/company-news/2025/01-29-2025-211638615
  57. RLI EPS – Earnings per Share 2010-2025 – Macrotrends, accessed August 30, 2025, https://macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/RLI/rli/eps-earnings-per-share-diluted
  58. The Progressive Corporation 2024 Annual Report, accessed August 30, 2025, https://s202.q4cdn.com/605347829/files/doc_financials/2024/q4/interactive/pdfs/Progressive-2024-AR.pdf
  59. Arch Capital Group Revenue 2010-2025 | ACGL – Macrotrends, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/ACGL/arch-capital-group/revenue
  60. Kinsale Capital Group (NYSE:KNSL) – Earnings & Revenue Performance – Simply Wall St, accessed August 30, 2025, https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/insurance/nyse-knsl/kinsale-capital-group/past
  61. Kinsale Capital Group (KNSL) – Revenue – Companies Market Cap, accessed August 30, 2025, https://companiesmarketcap.com/kinsale-capital/revenue/
  62. Primerica Reports Fourth Quarter 2024 Results, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investors.primerica.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/341/primerica-reports-fourth-quarter-2024-results
  63. Primerica, Inc. 2020 Annual Report, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/p/NYSE_PRI_2020.pdf
  64. The Travelers Companies, Inc. – Annual Reports, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/t/NYSE_TRV_2019.pdf
  65. Travelers Reports Record Net and Core Income per Diluted Share in Fourth Quarter 2019, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investor.travelers.com/newsroom/press-releases/news-details/2020/Travelers-Reports-Record-Net-and-Core-Income-per-Diluted-Share-in-Fourth-Quarter-2019/default.aspx
  66. Primerica Reports Fourth Quarter 2019 Results, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investors.primerica.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/54/primerica-reports-fourth-quarter-2019-results
  67. examination report of berkley regional insurance company urbandale, iowa as of december 31, 2022, accessed August 30, 2025, https://iid.iowa.gov/media/866/download
  68. 2019 ANNUAL REPORT – Selective Insurance, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.selective.com/~/media/Files/S/Selective-V2/2019-annual-report.pdf
  69. News Releases | 2019 – Selective Insurance, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.selective.com/investors/news-and-filings/company-news/2019
  70. Chubb Limited Annual Report 2019, accessed August 30, 2025, https://s1.q4cdn.com/677769242/files/doc_financials/2020/ar/2019-Chubb-Limited-Annual-Report.pdf
  71. Chubb Fire & Security Group – SEC.gov, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1796209/000119312521270843/d201971dex991.htm
  72. RLI Earnings Release – SEC.gov, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/84246/000008424620000002/rli-20200122ex991b9382e.htm
  73. Progressive Reports May 2019 Results, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investors.progressive.com/financials/financial-news-releases/news-details/2019/Progressive-Reports-May-2019-Results/default.aspx
  74. Financial Highlights | The Progressive Corporation 2019 Shareholders’ Report, accessed August 30, 2025, https://s202.q4cdn.com/605347829/files/doc_financials/2019/q1/interactive/financial.html
  75. Kinsale Capital Group – Annual Reports (10-K) – Companies Market Cap, accessed August 30, 2025, https://companiesmarketcap.com/kinsale-capital/annual-reports-10k/
  76. Travelers 2019 Annual Report, accessed August 30, 2025, https://s26.q4cdn.com/410417801/files/doc_financials/oar/travelersAR2019/index.html
  77. Primerica Reports Fourth Quarter 2020 Results, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investors.primerica.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/38/primerica-reports-fourth-quarter-2020-results
  78. Financials – Quarterly Results – W. R. Berkley Corporation – Investor Relations, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ir.berkley.com/financials/quarterly-results/default.aspx
  79. Selective Reports Fourth Quarter 2020 Net Income of $2.10 per Diluted Common Share and Non-GAAP Operating Income1 of, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.selective.com/~/media/Files/S/Selective-V2/reports-presentations/earnings/q4-2020-earnings.pdf
  80. Chubb Limited Annual Report 2020, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.chubb.com/content/dam/chubb-sites/chubb/about-chubb/pdfs/2020-Chubb-Annual-Report.pdf
  81. Progressive Revenue 2010-2025 | PGR – Macrotrends, accessed August 30, 2025, https://macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/PGR/progressive/revenue
  82. Arch Capital Group Ltd. Reports 2020 Fourth Quarter Results – Investor Relations, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ir.archgroup.com/news-events-presentations/press-releases/news-details/2021/Arch-Capital-Group-Ltd.-Reports-2020-Fourth-Quarter-Results/default.aspx
  83. ir.kinsalecapitalgroup.com, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ir.kinsalecapitalgroup.com/news/news-details/2021/Kinsale-Capital-Group-Inc.-Reports-2020-Fourth-Quarter-and-Year-End-Results-02-20-2021/default.aspx#:~:text=Net%20operating%20earnings(1)%20were%20%2472.3%20million%20%2C%20%243.16%20per,year%20ended%20December%2031%2C%202019%20.
  84. Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. Reports 2020 Fourth Quarter and Year-End Results, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ir.kinsalecapitalgroup.com/news/news-details/2021/Kinsale-Capital-Group-Inc.-Reports-2020-Fourth-Quarter-and-Year-End-Results-02-20-2021/default.aspx
  85. News – RLI Corp – Investor relations, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investors.rlicorp.com/news/default.aspx
  86. RLI Reports Second Quarter 2025 Results, accessed August 30, 2025, https://s204.q4cdn.com/949661285/files/doc_news/RLI-Reports-Second-Quarter-2025-Results-2025.pdf
  87. News & Events – Chubb Limited – Investor Relations, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investors.chubb.com/News–Events/news/default.aspx
  88. Primerica (PRI) Q2 2025 Earnings Call Transcript | The Motley Fool, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.fool.com/earnings/call-transcripts/2025/08/07/primerica-pri-q2-2025-earnings-call-transcript/
  89. W. R. Berkley Corporation Reports Second Quarter 2025 Results, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ir.berkley.com/news/news-details/2025/W–R–Berkley-Corporation-Reports-Second-Quarter-2025-Results/default.aspx
  90. AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of The Travelers Companies, Inc. and Main Subsidiaries, accessed August 30, 2025, https://news.ambest.com/pr/PressContent.aspx?refnum=36328&altsrc=2
  91. AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Chubb Limited and Its Subsidiaries, accessed August 30, 2025, https://news.ambest.com/newscontent.aspx?refnum=230492&altsrc=23
  92. Berkley Insurance Company – Company Profile – A.M. Best Information Services, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ratings.ambest.com/companyprofile.aspx?ambnum=3630&URatingId=-1&bl=64&AltSrc=3&PPP=&AltNum=15883630&Ext_User=&Ext_Misc=&Portal=0
  93. AM Best Revises Outlooks to Positive for RLI Corp. and Its Subsidiaries, accessed August 30, 2025, https://news.ambest.com/PR/PressContent.aspx?altsrc=2&refnum=35693
  94. AM Best’s Credit Ratings, accessed August 30, 2025, https://web.ambest.com/docs/default-source/events/credit_rating_monitor_11-23_global_a4.pdf?sfvrsn=3af4e92b_4
  95. AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of Kinsale Insurance Company and Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. – Business Wire, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20250812061701/en/AM-Best-Affirms-Credit-Ratings-of-Kinsale-Insurance-Company-and-Kinsale-Capital-Group-Inc.
  96. Selective Insurance Company of America – Company Profile – Best’s Credit Rating Center, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ratings.ambest.com/CompanyProfile.aspx?amb=826&AltNum=694826
  97. A.M. Best Affirms Ratings of Primerica, Inc. and Its Subsidiaries, accessed August 30, 2025, https://news.ambest.com/newscontent.aspx?refnum=193218&altsrc=23
  98. Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI), accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.selective.com/~/media/Files/S/Selective-V2/reports-presentations/earnings/2q-2025-call-transcript.pdf
  99. Financial Highlights – Travelers Sustainability Report, accessed August 30, 2025, https://sustainability.travelers.com/financial-performance/financial-highlights
  100. Moody’s Affirms Primerica’s Ratings Upon Announced Acquisition of e-TeleQuote; Outlook Stable, accessed August 30, 2025, https://news.primerica.com/moodys-affirms-primericas-ratings-upon-announced-acquisition-of-e-telequote-outlook-stable/
  101. WRB Investor Relations – W R Berkley Corp – Alpha Spread, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.alphaspread.com/security/nyse/wrb/investor-relations
  102. Selective Insurance Group Inc.’s Proposed Senior Unsecured Notes Rated ‘BBB’, accessed August 30, 2025, https://disclosure.spglobal.com/ratings/pt/regulatory/article/-/view/type/HTML/id/3326407
  103. Third-Party Financial Ratings – Progressive, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.progressive.com/auto/ratings/
  104. Moody’s affirms Progressive’s ratings (A2 senior unsecured), outlook stable – ResearchPool, accessed August 30, 2025, https://app.researchpool.com/provider/moodys-investors-service/pgr-moodys-affirms-progressives-ratings-a2-senior-unsecured-outlook-stable-Q52DrLsFyF
  105. Case 99 Arch Capital Group Ltd – IDEAS/RePEc, accessed August 30, 2025, https://ideas.repec.org/h/spr/mgmchp/978-3-031-50032-9_99.html
  106. Moody’s Investors Service revised outlook on Arch Capital Group Inc. to positive and affirmed at “Baa1” (LT- local currency) credit rating – Cbonds, accessed August 30, 2025, https://cbonds.com/news/2798057/
  107. August 2025, accessed August 30, 2025, https://s29.q4cdn.com/479990906/files/doc_presentations/2025/Aug/04/August-2025-Kinsale-IR-Presentation.pdf
  108. Travelers Insurance Co. of Canada ‘AA-‘ Ratings P – S&P Global, accessed August 30, 2025, https://disclosure.spglobal.com/ratings/en/regulatory/article/-/view/type/HTML/id/3378861
  109. Does Travelers’ insurance rating indicate a strong carrier?, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/us/guides/does-travelers-insurance-rating-indicate-a-strong-carrier-543761.aspx
  110. S&P Global Ratings affirms Primerica at “A-” (Local Currency LT credit rating) – Cbonds, accessed August 30, 2025, https://cbonds.com/news/2415871/
  111. Moody’s Investors Service affirms Primerica at “Baa1” (LT- local currency credit rating), accessed August 30, 2025, https://cbonds.com/news/2961205/
  112. S&P Global Ratings affirms W.R. Berkley at “BBB+” (Local Currency LT credit rating); outlook positive – Cbonds, accessed August 30, 2025, https://cbonds.com/news/3282669/
  113. Moody’s Investors Service affirms W.R. Berkley at “Baa1” (LT- local currency credit rating); outlook stable – Cbonds, accessed August 30, 2025, https://cbonds.com/news/2824383/
  114. South Carolina | Insurance | Reports – Moody’s, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.moodys.com/researchandratings/region/north-america/south-carolina/03F017/005009
  115. S&P Global Ratings affirms Chubb at “A” (Local Currency LT credit rating); outlook stable, accessed August 30, 2025, https://cbonds.com/news/3246399/
  116. Moody’s Investors Service upgrades LT- local currency credit rating of Chubb INA Holdings to “A2” from “A3”; outlook stable – Cbonds, accessed August 30, 2025, https://cbonds.com/news/3088663/
  117. AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of RLI Corp. and Its Subsidiaries, accessed August 30, 2025, https://news.ambest.com/newscontent.aspx?refnum=229521
  118. AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of RLI Corp. and Its Subsidiaries, accessed August 30, 2025, https://news.ambest.com/newscontent.aspx?refnum=238007
  119. KNSL Investor Relations – Kinsale Capital Group Inc – Alpha Spread, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.alphaspread.com/security/nyse/knsl/investor-relations
  120. W. R. Berkley (WRB) Q1 2025 Earnings Call – The Motley Fool, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.fool.com/earnings/call-transcripts/2025/04/22/w-r-berkley-wrb-q1-2025-earnings-call/
  121. Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) Revenue 2015-2025 – Stock Analysis, accessed August 30, 2025, https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/sigi/revenue/
  122. Kinsale Capital – 9 Year Stock Price History | KNSL – Macrotrends, accessed August 30, 2025, https://macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/KNSL/kinsale-capital/stock-price-history
  123. Travelers Reports First Quarter Net Income of $395 Million and Core Income of $443 Million, accessed August 30, 2025, https://investor.travelers.com/newsroom/press-releases/news-details/2025/Travelers-Reports-First-Quarter-Net-Income-of-395-Million-and-Core-Income-of-443-Million/default.aspx
  124. Earnings call transcript: Selective Insurance Q2 2025 shows EPS miss, stock drops, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.investing.com/news/transcripts/earnings-call-transcript-selective-insurance-q2-2025-shows-eps-miss-stock-drops-93CH-4204874
  125. Managing Our Business Responsibly – Chubb, accessed August 30, 2025, https://about.chubb.com/governance/business-practices.html
  126. Our Values – Primerica, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.primerica.com/public/our-values.html
  127. Primerica, Inc. (PRI) Stock Price, Market Cap, Segmented Revenue & Earnings – Datainsightsmarket.com, accessed August 30, 2025, https://www.datainsightsmarket.com/companies/PRI