Executive Summary & Investment Profile

AutoNation Inc. (NYSE: AN) stands as the largest automotive retailer in the United States, operating a highly diversified and integrated business model. The company’s core operations encompass the sale of new and used vehicles, a resilient and high-margin after-sales parts and service division, and a rapidly expanding in-house financing arm, AutoNation Finance. Positioned as a leading consolidator within a historically fragmented industry, AutoNation leverages its significant scale to drive operational efficiencies, enhance its competitive moat, and generate substantial shareholder returns, primarily through a disciplined and aggressive share repurchase program.

The investment profile of AutoNation is multifaceted, characterized by a mature, cash-generative core business that is inherently exposed to the cyclicality of consumer demand and macroeconomic conditions. This cyclicality is counterbalanced by the stability of its high-margin service segment, which benefits from the growing age of vehicles on U.S. roads. Furthermore, the company is actively pursuing strategic growth initiatives in digital retail and captive financing to adapt to evolving consumer behaviors and capture a greater share of the value chain.

This analysis will explore the central investment thesis that AutoNation’s formidable scale, diversified and counter-cyclical revenue streams, and disciplined capital allocation strategy position it favorably to navigate the automotive retail industry’s profound cyclical and structural transformations. Key themes under examination include the sustainability of post-pandemic vehicle margins as inventory levels normalize, the efficacy of its strategic pivots towards electric vehicles (EVs) and an omnichannel digital experience, and its capacity to continue consolidating the market to create durable shareholder value.

The bull case for AutoNation is predicated on its scale advantage in an industry ripe for further consolidation, the defensive characteristics of its After-Sales business, a value-accretive share repurchase program, and the strategic expansion into in-house financing. Conversely, the bear case centers on its cyclical exposure to economic downturns and rising interest rates, the potential for significant margin compression as market dynamics normalize, intense competition from both traditional and digital-native retailers, and the inherent execution risks associated with the industry’s transition toward electrification and digital-first retail models.

Company Analysis: A Diversified Automotive Retail Platform

Business Model & Operations

AutoNation’s operational framework is built upon a comprehensive automotive retail model that provides a full suite of products and services to consumers throughout the vehicle ownership lifecycle.¹ The company’s physical footprint is strategically concentrated in the high-growth Sunbelt region of the United States. Approximately 65% of its total retail new vehicle sales are generated by dealerships located in Florida, California, and Texas.² This geographic focus provides significant exposure to favorable demographic and economic trends in these states but concurrently concentrates risk related to regional economic downturns or natural disasters. The business is organized to capture revenue across the entire value chain, from the initial vehicle sale to ongoing maintenance and eventual trade-in.

Revenue & Gross Profit Streams

The company’s financial results are driven by four principal business lines, each possessing distinct margin profiles, growth drivers, and degrees of sensitivity to the economic cycle. This diversification is a cornerstone of its business model.

• New Vehicles: This segment is the largest contributor to revenue, reporting $3.4 billion in Q2 2025, an increase of 9% year-over-year. This growth was propelled by a 7% to 8% increase in same-store retail unit sales, indicating a recovery in both consumer demand and vehicle supply from manufacturers.⁴ Historically, this segment operates on the lowest gross margins within the portfolio, and its profitability is highly sensitive to fluctuations in manufacturer production, inventory levels in the retail channel, and the level of incentives offered to consumers.
• Used Vehicles: Representing a significant portion of sales, this segment generated revenue of $2.0 billion in Q2 2025, a 4% year-over-year increase, supported by a 6% rise in same-store unit sales.⁴ Gross profit per unit (GPU) has demonstrated relative stability, hovering between $1,627 and $1,650 in recent periods.⁴ The used vehicle market provides a valuable hedge against new vehicle supply constraints and offers a more affordable entry point for consumers, particularly in times of economic uncertainty.
• After-Sales (Parts & Service): This segment is the company’s most profitable and stable business line. In Q2 2025, it posted revenue of $1.2 billion, a robust 12% year-over-year increase, with gross profit growing in tandem by 12% to 13%.⁴ The non-discretionary nature of many repair and maintenance services provides a resilient, recurring revenue stream that is less correlated with the broader economic cycle than vehicle sales.
• Customer Financial Services (F&I): This high-margin segment generated $363 million in revenue in Q2 2025, a 13% year-over-year increase.⁴ Revenue is derived from arranging financing for customers and selling a portfolio of vehicle protection products, such as extended service contracts and guaranteed asset protection (GAP) insurance. Profitability in this segment is closely tied to vehicle sales volume and the company’s ability to increase its finance and insurance penetration rate per vehicle sold.

Segment Performance Analysis

AutoNation provides a further level of detail by reporting performance across three distinct vehicle brand segments, in addition to its captive finance arm. This breakdown reveals important underlying trends in consumer preferences and manufacturer performance.

• Domestic: This segment, which includes brands such as Ford, General Motors, and Stellantis, demonstrated remarkable strength in Q2 2025. Segment income surged by 83% year-over-year to $92 million, driven by a 10% increase in revenue.⁴ The most telling metric was the 19% year-over-year and 14% sequential growth in same-store new unit sales.⁵ This powerful performance suggests that the significant supply chain disruptions that had previously hampered domestic automakers have largely abated, allowing them to meet pent-up demand. This normalization of supply, however, carries the risk of a more competitive pricing environment, which could pressure the historically high new vehicle margins that dealers have enjoyed since the pandemic.
• Import: Comprising brands like Toyota, Honda, and Hyundai, the Import segment continued its steady performance, with segment income growing 23% year-over-year to $133 million in Q2 2025.⁴
• Premium Luxury: This segment, featuring brands such as Mercedes-Benz, BMW, and Lexus, remains AutoNation’s largest contributor to both revenue ($2.6 billion in Q2 2025) and segment income ($180 million). It posted impressive income growth of 27% year-over-year, underscoring the resilience of the luxury consumer segment.⁴
• AutoNation Finance: The company’s strategic push into in-house financing is yielding positive results. The segment generated $2 million in income in Q2 2025, a notable turnaround from a loss in the prior-year period. A critical milestone was the successful completion of a $700 million asset-backed securitization, which provides a stable and scalable funding mechanism for future loan portfolio growth and reduces reliance on third-party capital markets.⁴

Franchise Relationships & Portfolio

AutoNation’s business model is fundamentally built upon its franchise agreements with automotive manufacturers (Original Equipment Manufacturers, or OEMs). These agreements grant the company the exclusive right to sell and service specific vehicle brands within designated geographic territories. This franchise system creates formidable barriers to entry for new competitors, as OEMs carefully control the number and location of their dealerships. A core element of AutoNation’s long-term strategy involves actively managing its portfolio of franchises, divesting non-core or underperforming stores, and strategically acquiring dealerships that align with its goal of diversifying towards higher-demand volume import and premium luxury brands.⁸

The After-Sales segment functions as a crucial defensive moat and a primary engine for funding shareholder returns, effectively cushioning the consolidated business from the full volatility inherent in vehicle sales cycles. The data from Q2 2025 shows After-Sales gross profit expanding by 12%, significantly outpacing the 8% total revenue growth and showcasing superior margin stability.⁴ This operational strength is supported by a powerful secular trend: the average age of vehicles on U.S. roads has climbed to over 12.5 years.⁹ As vehicles age, they require more frequent and often more complex maintenance and repairs, creating a growing, non-discretionary, and recurring revenue stream for AutoNation’s service bays. This highly reliable, high-margin cash flow provides a stable financial foundation that enables the company to consistently fund its aggressive share repurchase program—which totaled $254 million in the first half of 2025—and pursue strategic acquisitions, even when vehicle sales margins are under pressure.⁷ Consequently, the performance of the After-Sales division is not merely an operational detail but a central pillar of AutoNation’s financial strategy and a key determinant of its long-term investment merit.

Industry Dynamics & Market Position

Market Landscape & Growth

The automotive retail industry is a vast and integral part of the global economy. In 2024, the global market was valued at $3.92 trillion and is projected to expand at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 7.15% through 2032, with North America remaining the dominant regional market.¹⁰ The industry is currently in a state of transition, moving beyond the unprecedented disruptions of the COVID-19 pandemic. Key market dynamics in 2024 and 2025 include the normalization of new vehicle inventory levels after prolonged shortages and the impact of a fluctuating interest rate environment on vehicle affordability and consumer demand.¹¹

Industry Consolidation Trend

The U.S. automotive dealership market, while still highly fragmented, is undergoing a period of rapid and accelerating consolidation, described by industry experts as occurring at “breakneck speed”.¹² In the last three and a half years alone, more than 2,000 dealerships have been acquired, a transaction rate nearly double the historical average.¹³

This trend is propelled by two primary forces. First, many multi-generational, family-owned dealership groups are facing succession planning challenges, making a sale to a larger entity an attractive exit strategy. Second, there is a growing recognition that scale is critical for future success. Larger groups can achieve significant operational efficiencies in areas such as marketing, information technology, human resources, and inventory management, which are difficult for smaller operators to replicate.¹³

As one of the largest publicly traded dealership groups, AutoNation is a pivotal player in this consolidation wave. Its growth strategy is heavily reliant on acquiring smaller dealers to build “super-regional” clusters that can dominate local markets.¹³ The scale of this activity is substantial, with public groups collectively spending $2.7 billion on U.S. acquisitions in 2023.¹⁵ This ongoing consolidation is reshaping the competitive landscape, creating a market increasingly dominated by a handful of large, well-capitalized players.

Competitive Landscape

Competition within automotive retail is intense and originates from multiple sources.

• Traditional Dealers: AutoNation’s most direct competitors are other large, publicly traded dealership groups, including Lithia Motors (which surpassed AutoNation in new vehicle sales volume in 2022), Penske Automotive Group, Asbury Automotive Group, and Group 1 Automotive.¹⁶ Beyond these public peers, AutoNation competes with thousands of smaller private dealership groups across the country. The principal competitive factors in this arena are dealership location, quality of service, vehicle pricing, and the breadth of selection offered.²⁰
• Online Platforms: The rise of digital-native retailers such as Carvana and Vroom introduced a disruptive, online-first sales model that challenged the traditional dealership experience.¹⁸ However, the initial threat has been partially mitigated as incumbent dealers like AutoNation have invested heavily in developing their own sophisticated omnichannel capabilities.
• OEM Direct Sales: A persistent long-term structural risk to the dealership model is the potential for OEMs to sell vehicles directly to consumers, bypassing the franchised dealer network entirely. This model has been successfully pioneered by Tesla.²¹ At present, this threat is largely held in check by a complex web of state-level franchise laws that protect dealers’ exclusive rights to sell new vehicles in their designated territories.

Barriers to Entry & Competitive Moats

The franchised dealership system itself constitutes the most significant barrier to entry in the new vehicle retail market. Franchise agreements with OEMs are limited in number, geographically protected, and extremely difficult for new entrants to obtain. Within this protected ecosystem, AutoNation has cultivated a powerful competitive moat built on its industry-leading scale. This scale confers several key advantages:

• Economies of Scale: The ability to negotiate more favorable terms with suppliers, centralize costly back-office functions like accounting and IT, and deploy larger and more efficient marketing campaigns.¹³
• Data & Analytics: AutoNation’s operations generate a massive trove of data from millions of customer sales and service transactions. The company leverages this data to optimize vehicle pricing, manage inventory across its network, and execute highly targeted marketing initiatives, a capability smaller competitors cannot match.²²
• Brand Recognition: In an industry largely composed of local and regional players, AutoNation has established a national brand identity, which can foster greater consumer trust and awareness.²⁴

The powerful consolidation trend is bifurcating the market, creating a “barbell” structure composed of large, technologically advanced, and well-capitalized groups like AutoNation on one end, and thousands of small, localized dealers on the other. This dynamic serves to both enhance the competitive moat of the large players and, simultaneously, create a continuous and rich pipeline of potential acquisition targets. The top 10 dealership groups now control an all-time high of 9.3% of all U.S. dealerships, a figure that is steadily rising.¹⁴ The immense scale of these consolidators allows for substantial investments in proprietary technology, such as AI-driven pricing tools and integrated digital retail platforms, which smaller competitors cannot afford, thereby widening the competitive divide.²⁵ Despite this consolidation, the market remains overwhelmingly fragmented, with 92% of dealers still owning between one and five stores.¹⁴ These smaller operations represent prime acquisition targets for groups like AutoNation, which are strategically focused on building regional density to unlock operational synergies.¹³ This creates a self-reinforcing cycle where the act of consolidation strengthens the acquirers’ market position and simultaneously provides the fuel, in the form of acquisition opportunities, for future growth.

Furthermore, the evolution of consumer behavior towards an omnichannel model—which blends online research with essential in-person experiences—has blunted the disruptive threat from pure-play online retailers and instead plays to the core strengths of incumbent dealers with established physical infrastructure. Industry data reveals that while a significant portion of consumers (43%) now utilize an omnichannel approach, the physical dealership remains critical; 80% of buyers still want at least one test drive, and 35% rank in-person product expertise as a top priority.¹⁰ This hybrid purchasing journey challenges the thesis of a complete shift to online-only transactions, a model that has proven to be highly capital-intensive and difficult to operate profitably for digital-native disruptors. Companies like AutoNation, which possess an extensive physical network of dealerships and service centers alongside significant investments in their “AutoNation Express” digital platform, are uniquely positioned to cater to this modern consumer.²² This integrated “clicks-and-bricks” model provides a durable competitive advantage over both pure-online retailers, who lack the critical service and delivery infrastructure, and smaller traditional dealers, who lack the capital and expertise to build sophisticated digital tools.

Recent Industry Challenges & Changes (2023-2025)

Inventory Normalization

Following years of severe supply chain disruptions and semiconductor shortages that crippled automotive production during the pandemic, new vehicle inventory levels fully recovered in 2024, returning to a state of equilibrium near pre-pandemic norms.¹¹ This normalization has fundamentally altered market dynamics. The pricing power that dealers enjoyed during the period of scarcity has shifted back toward consumers. This has resulted in a notable increase in manufacturer incentives and a steady moderation of the record-high new vehicle gross margins that characterized the 2021-2023 period.

Interest Rate Environment

The sharp rise in interest rates throughout 2023 and into 2024 significantly increased the cost of auto financing, creating a substantial headwind for the industry by pressuring consumer affordability and dampening sales volumes.¹¹ The initial move by the Federal Reserve to lower rates in late 2024 provided some measure of relief to the market.¹¹ AutoNation is directly exposed to this macroeconomic factor through the profitability of its F&I segment, the demand for its vehicles, and its own floorplan interest expenses used to finance its inventory.

Electric Vehicle (EV) Transition

The ongoing structural shift toward electric vehicles is one of the most significant transformations facing the automotive retail industry.

• Adoption Rate: The pace of adoption is accelerating. EV sales are projected to comprise 20-25% of all U.S. new car sales in 2025, a substantial increase from approximately 12% in 2024.²⁵ AutoNation’s own results reflect this trend, with its battery electric vehicle (BEV) sales growing nearly 20% year-over-year in the second quarter of 2025.⁵
• Challenges and Implications: This transition is not without significant challenges for the traditional dealership model. EVs have fewer moving parts and require less routine maintenance, which poses a long-term threat to the high-margin After-Sales revenue stream. Furthermore, dealers must make substantial capital investments in charging infrastructure and specialized technician training to support EV sales and service. Managing a complex inventory mix of both internal combustion engine (ICE) and electric vehicles also presents new operational hurdles.
• Consumer Sentiment and the Rise of Hybrids: Recent consumer studies have revealed a degree of “muted” inertia regarding the adoption of pure BEVs, with a notable uptick in interest for hybrid vehicles.²⁸ Many consumers view hybrids as a “best of both worlds” solution, offering improved fuel efficiency and lower emissions without the range anxiety and charging infrastructure concerns associated with pure EVs. This trend is clearly visible in AutoNation’s performance, where hybrid sales surged by 40% in Q2 2025, double the growth rate of its BEV sales.³⁰

Supply Chain & Geopolitical Risks

The automotive industry remains vulnerable to global supply chain disruptions and geopolitical tensions. The ongoing threat of new tariffs on imported vehicles and parts could significantly increase vehicle prices, which would likely dampen consumer demand and could invalidate industry sales forecasts for 2025.⁹

Regulatory Landscape

The automotive retail sector operates within a highly regulated environment. State-level franchise laws are a critical component of this landscape, as they provide significant protection to dealers by restricting OEMs from selling vehicles directly to consumers.² Concurrently, increasingly stringent federal and state environmental standards are a primary catalyst accelerating the industry’s transition toward electric vehicles.

The notable consumer pivot towards hybrid vehicles presents a crucial “bridging” opportunity for incumbent dealers like AutoNation. This trend allows them to de-risk the complex and capital-intensive transition to a fully electric future by leveraging their existing service capabilities. Consumer surveys and AutoNation’s own sales data confirm a growing preference for hybrids, driven by practical concerns over charging infrastructure and range.²⁸ Because hybrid vehicles still contain internal combustion engines, they require many of the same high-margin maintenance and repair services as traditional gasoline-powered cars. This dynamic mitigates the significant long-term risk of service revenue erosion that a market dominated by pure BEVs would entail. By effectively catering to this strong hybrid demand, AutoNation can preserve the profitability of its vital After-Sales business while strategically using the time and cash flow generated to make the necessary investments in training and equipment for an eventual all-electric market. This transforms the EV transition from a potentially disruptive cliff-edge event into a more manageable, multi-year evolution.

Financial Performance & Trends

The financial performance of AutoNation reflects a company navigating the post-pandemic normalization of the automotive market, with resilient growth in its service-oriented segments offsetting margin pressures in its core vehicle sales business.

Financial Metric	FY 2021	FY 2022	FY 2023	FY 2024	H1 2025
Total Revenue ($M)	Data Not Provided	Data Not Provided	$27,000 (est.)	$26,650 (est.)	$13,664.8
Gross Profit ($M)	Data Not Provided	Data Not Provided	$5,129.0 (est.)	$4,785.4	$2,495.3
Gross Margin (%)	Data Not Provided	Data Not Provided	19.0% (est.)	18.0% (est.)	18.3%
Operating Income ($M)	Data Not Provided	Data Not Provided	$1,700 (est.)	$1,325 (est.)	$553.6
Operating Margin (%)	Data Not Provided	Data Not Provided	6.3% (est.)	5.0% (est.)	4.1%
Net Income ($M)	Data Not Provided	Data Not Provided	$1,021 (est.)	$692.2	$261.9
Diluted EPS ($)	Data Not Provided	Data Not Provided	$22.74	$16.92	$6.73
Share Repurchases ($M)	Data Not Provided	Data Not Provided	Data Not Provided	Data Not Provided	$254.0

Revenue & Margin Analysis

AutoNation’s top-line performance has shown resilience. In the second quarter of 2025, total revenue grew 8% year-over-year to $7.0 billion, and for the first half of the year, revenue increased 5% to $13.7 billion.⁴ This growth was broad-based, with strong contributions from After-Sales (+12%), Customer Financial Services (+13%), and New Vehicles (+9%), while the Used Vehicle segment posted more modest growth of 4%.⁴ This contrasts with the full-year 2024 results, where revenue experienced a slight decline of 1.3% from the prior year, reflecting the tougher market conditions during that period.²

A key positive development has been the trend in gross profit. In Q2 2025, total gross profit expanded by 10%, outpacing revenue growth and leading to a 40 basis point improvement in the overall gross margin to 18.3%.⁵ This margin expansion was a direct result of the company’s diversified business model; strong performance and higher margins in the After-Sales and Used Vehicle segments successfully offset the anticipated and ongoing moderation in new vehicle profitability.⁵ This dynamic was a reversal from the full-year 2024 trend, where total gross profit fell by 6.7% due to significant pressure on vehicle margins.²

Profitability & Returns

On a GAAP basis, AutoNation’s earnings have been affected by significant non-cash charges. In Q2 2025, GAAP Diluted EPS fell 29% to $2.26, a figure heavily impacted by goodwill and franchise rights impairment charges.⁴ However, a clearer picture of the company’s core operational profitability is provided by its adjusted earnings. Adjusted Diluted EPS, which excludes these one-time items, surged an impressive 37% year-over-year to $5.46 in Q2 2025.⁴ For the full fiscal year 2024, Diluted EPS was $16.92, a decrease from $22.74 in 2023, reflecting the broader margin pressures experienced during that year.²

The company has historically generated strong returns on capital. While recent data points vary, with some sources citing a return on equity (ROE) of 7.22% and others pointing to historical levels closer to 29%, the overall business model has proven to be highly profitable and efficient at generating returns for shareholders.²⁶

Cash Flow & Working Capital

AutoNation’s cash flow profile in the first half of 2025 reflects its strategic decision to invest heavily in its growing finance arm. The company reported cash used in operating activities of $230 million for the period.⁷ This use of cash was not due to operational weakness but was instead primarily driven by a substantial $695 million increase in auto loans receivable on the balance sheet as the AutoNation Finance segment ramped up its loan originations.⁷ When adjusting for this strategic investment, the company’s underlying cash generation remains robust. Adjusted free cash flow for the first half of 2025 was a healthy $394 million.⁷

The significant divergence between GAAP EPS and Adjusted EPS in recent reporting periods underscores a critical analytical point: the necessity of separating one-time, non-cash accounting charges from the underlying operational performance of the business. The Q2 2025 GAAP EPS of $2.26 was weighed down by $3.21 per share in after-tax, non-cash impairments related to goodwill and franchise rights.⁴ Such charges, while reflecting a downward revision of the long-term value of specific assets, do not impact the company’s immediate cash-generating ability. The powerful 37% year-over-year growth in Adjusted EPS, which strips out these non-recurring items, provides a much clearer indication of the health of the core business engine. This adjusted figure, driven by strong volumes and profitability in After-Sales and F&I, suggests that the fundamental operations remain robust despite the accounting write-downs.

Growth Strategy & Opportunities

AutoNation’s growth strategy is a multi-pronged approach focused on leveraging its scale, expanding its service offerings, and embracing digital innovation to enhance the customer experience and capture greater market share.

Acquisition Strategy

Consolidation remains a cornerstone of AutoNation’s growth plan. The company actively pursues acquisitions of individual dealerships and small- to medium-sized dealership groups to expand its geographic footprint, enter new markets, and build regional scale.² A recent example of this strategy in action was the acquisition of two stores in Colorado in April 2025.³² The company’s ability to efficiently integrate these acquisitions and realize operational synergies is a core competency that drives value creation.

Digital Transformation & Omnichannel Experience

The “AutoNation Express” platform is the centerpiece of the company’s digital strategy. This integrated digital retailing solution is designed to provide customers with a seamless and intuitive omnichannel experience, empowering them to complete as much or as little of the vehicle transaction process online as they prefer. This includes browsing a vast inventory, calculating payments, applying for financing, getting an instant trade-in offer, and scheduling in-store pickup or at-home delivery.²² This digital-first approach is not just about convenience; it is a key driver of efficiency. The company has reported that its digital initiatives have helped reduce overhead costs, while the use of AI-powered tools has improved operational efficiency by as much as 68% and boosted showroom appointment rates.²⁶ The impact is significant, with 45% of all vehicle sales now being initiated through its online channels.²⁷

After-Sales Expansion

Recognizing the stability and high profitability of its parts and service business, management has made its expansion a strategic priority, with a stated goal of capturing all of a customer’s vehicle service needs throughout their ownership lifecycle.³³ This involves actively expanding the technician workforce to increase service capacity and leveraging its vast customer dataset to offer predictive maintenance services.²⁶ Management has guided for continued mid-single-digit growth in this crucial segment.³⁰

AutoNation Finance

The strategic expansion of the in-house finance arm, AutoNation Finance, is a key initiative aimed at vertically integrating the business and capturing a larger share of the profit from each vehicle transaction.² By providing direct financing to customers, AutoNation can increase its finance penetration rates and retain the interest margin that would otherwise be captured by third-party lenders.

Electric Vehicles (EVs)

AutoNation is actively positioning itself to capitalize on the industry’s secular shift toward electrification. The company is strategically building out its inventory of new and used EVs, investing in the necessary charging infrastructure at its dealerships, and implementing comprehensive training programs for its sales and service technicians. The strong sales growth in both hybrid and battery electric vehicles, which were up 40% and 20% respectively in Q2 2025, demonstrates that these early investments are gaining traction with consumers.²⁶

AutoNation’s digital strategy extends far beyond simple e-commerce; it is fundamentally about leveraging data as a powerful competitive asset to create a personalized, high-margin, and loyal customer ecosystem. The company’s emphasis on proprietary tools like “Customer 360” and the “Equity Mining Tool” is central to this effort.²² These platforms harness a massive dataset covering over nine million customers, allowing AutoNation to analyze individual service histories, purchase propensities, and household vehicle ownership. This deep understanding enables highly effective and proactive marketing. For instance, the system can automatically identify an existing service customer whose vehicle is an ideal candidate for a trade-in and generate a personalized offer for a newer model with a similar or even lower monthly payment. This data-driven approach fosters a “sticky” customer relationship, increases retention rates for both sales and service, drives traffic to high-margin service bays, and generates a pipeline of efficient, targeted sales leads. This creates a higher lifetime customer value and represents a significant, hard-to-replicate competitive advantage derived directly from the company’s unmatched scale.

Capital Allocation & Shareholder Returns

AutoNation’s capital allocation strategy is disciplined and clearly prioritized, with a primary focus on returning capital to shareholders through an aggressive share repurchase program, supplemented by investments in strategic growth initiatives and acquisitions.

Share Repurchase Program

The cornerstone of AutoNation’s shareholder return policy is its share repurchase program. The company has a long and consistent track record of being an aggressive buyer of its own stock, viewing it as a highly efficient method of creating shareholder value.

• In the first half of 2025, AutoNation deployed $254 million to repurchase 1.5 million shares at an average price of approximately $164 per share.⁷
• As of the end of the second quarter of 2025, the company had more than $607 million remaining under its existing share repurchase authorization, signaling a continued commitment to this strategy.⁷
• These buybacks have had a material impact on financial results, significantly reducing the number of shares outstanding. In Q2 2025, the weighted average diluted share count was down 6% year-over-year, providing a powerful mechanical boost to earnings per share (EPS) growth.⁴

Dividend Policy

In line with its focus on repurchases, AutoNation currently does not pay a cash dividend to common shareholders.²¹ While historical records indicate the company paid dividends in the late 1990s, this practice was discontinued in favor of reinvesting capital into the business and executing share buybacks.³⁷

Capital Expenditures (CapEx)

The company continues to invest in its physical and digital infrastructure to support long-term growth. Capital expenditures totaled $154 million in the first half of 2025.⁷ These investments are typically directed toward dealership maintenance and modernization, technology platform enhancements, and the expansion of its service capacity.

Debt Management

AutoNation operates with a significant amount of debt on its balance sheet, a common feature of the capital-intensive auto retail industry.² As of June 30, 2025, the company’s covenant leverage ratio stood at a manageable 2.33x ⁶, and total debt was approximately $9.03 billion.³⁴ The management of this leverage, particularly in a fluctuating interest rate environment, is a critical aspect of the company’s financial strategy.

The company’s long-standing capital allocation policy signals a strong and unwavering conviction from management that its own stock is trading below its intrinsic value. By consistently prioritizing share repurchases over the initiation of a dividend, the company is making a clear statement that it believes buybacks are the most accretive use of capital for generating shareholder returns.⁸ A share repurchase is most effective when a stock’s market price is low relative to its earnings power. The low P/E multiple at which AutoNation’s stock often trades implies a high earnings yield (the inverse of the P/E ratio). By deploying hundreds of millions of dollars of free cash flow annually to repurchase shares, management is effectively “investing” at this attractive high earnings yield.⁷ This strategy creates a powerful compounding effect on EPS growth by systematically reducing the number of shares outstanding, a key factor that contributed to the 37% growth in Adjusted EPS in Q2 2025.⁵ For investors, this aggressive and consistent buyback policy demonstrates a strong alignment of interests with management and can be interpreted as a bullish internal signal regarding the company’s long-term prospects and valuation.

Management Quality & Corporate Governance

Leadership Team

AutoNation’s senior management team is composed of seasoned executives with deep experience in the automotive retail industry, complemented by leaders recruited from other sectors to bring new skills and perspectives to the company.²⁴ The Chief Executive Officer, Mike Manley, was appointed in November 2021. He brought extensive global automotive experience to the role, having previously served as CEO of Fiat Chrysler Automobiles (FCA) and Head of Americas for Stellantis.³⁸

Board of Directors

The company’s Board of Directors consists of nine nominees for 2025, the majority of whom are classified as independent. In a strong sign of good governance, the role of Chairman of the Board is held by an independent director, Rick L. Burdick, separating this function from the CEO role.³⁸ The board is characterized by a diversity of professional backgrounds, with directors possessing extensive experience in corporate finance, international law, real estate development, and consumer services, providing a broad range of expertise to guide company strategy.³⁸

Executive Compensation

AutoNation’s executive compensation framework is explicitly designed to align the interests of management with those of shareholders by linking a significant portion of pay to performance. The program consists of three primary components:

1. Base Salary: Provides a fixed level of compensation.
2. Annual Cash Incentive: A performance-based bonus tied to the achievement of a pre-set target for adjusted operating income per share.
3. Long-Term Incentives: Granted in the form of Restricted Stock Units (RSUs), these awards are directly linked to long-term value creation. A significant portion of these RSUs are performance-based, vesting only if the company achieves specific targets for Relative Total Shareholder Return (TSR) and Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) over a three-year period.³⁸ This structure incentivizes management to focus on both stock price appreciation relative to peers and the efficient use of capital.

Governance Practices

AutoNation has implemented a robust set of corporate governance policies that reflect best practices. Key features include:

• Majority Voting: In uncontested elections, directors must receive a majority of votes cast to be elected, and the board has a resignation policy for any incumbent director who fails to achieve this standard.
• Proxy Access: The company’s bylaws permit eligible long-term shareholders to nominate director candidates for inclusion in the company’s official proxy materials.
• Prohibition on Hedging: Directors and employees are strictly prohibited from engaging in hedging transactions or short sales of company stock, ensuring their economic interests remain aligned with those of other shareholders.
• Recoupment Policy: The company has adopted a formal “clawback” policy that mandates the recoupment of erroneously awarded incentive compensation in the event of a financial restatement.³⁸

Risk Factors & Potential Headwinds

An investment in AutoNation is subject to a range of risks inherent to the automotive retail industry and the broader economy. A thorough assessment of these potential headwinds is essential for any investment decision.

• Economic & Cyclical Risks: The automotive retail business is highly cyclical and sensitive to changes in the macroeconomic environment. Factors such as consumer confidence, unemployment levels, disposable income, and prevailing interest rates have a direct and significant impact on consumer demand for both new and used vehicles.² An economic downturn would almost certainly lead to a decline in sales volumes and profitability.
• Manufacturer & Inventory Risk: The company’s operations are fundamentally dependent on its relationships with automotive manufacturers. Any significant operational disruption, financial distress, or bankruptcy of a key OEM partner could severely impact AutoNation’s ability to source inventory, which would have a material adverse effect on its business.² Additionally, as inventory levels across the industry continue to normalize, there is a risk that the company may be unable to sell its vehicles at sufficiently profitable margins.
• Competitive & Disruption Risks: The industry is characterized by intense competition from other large public dealership groups, thousands of private dealers, and disruptive online platforms.² This competitive pressure could lead to an erosion of market share and margins. While currently mitigated by state franchise laws, the long-term structural threat of OEMs adopting a direct-to-consumer sales model remains a significant risk to the entire franchised dealer system.
• Interest Rate & Credit Risk: AutoNation is exposed to interest rate risk, primarily through its vehicle floorplan payables and other forms of variable-rate debt used to finance its operations.² A sustained period of high interest rates would increase its borrowing costs and negatively impact profitability. Furthermore, the strategic expansion of the AutoNation Finance segment introduces direct consumer credit risk to the company’s balance sheet; higher-than-expected loan defaults would result in increased credit losses.
• Regulatory & Geopolitical Risks: The company is subject to a wide array of regulations. New and more stringent environmental regulations could accelerate the costly transition to EVs. Any changes to the state franchise laws that currently protect dealers could fundamentally alter the industry’s structure and profitability. Geopolitically, the imposition of tariffs on imported vehicles or parts represents a significant and immediate threat, as it would likely lead to higher vehicle prices and could significantly dampen consumer demand.²
• Cybersecurity Risk: As a modern retailer, AutoNation relies heavily on its information technology systems and those of third-party providers for all aspects of its operations. This dependence makes the company vulnerable to cybersecurity threats. A significant data breach or system outage could lead to operational disruptions, financial losses, and reputational damage. The industry-wide disruption caused by the CDK systems outage, which was noted as having a financial impact in AutoNation’s Q2 2025 earnings call, serves as a recent and tangible example of this risk.²

Valuation Analysis

The valuation of AutoNation must be considered in the context of its publicly traded peers and its own historical trading ranges. The company’s valuation multiples suggest a mature, cyclical business, with the market assigning a notable discount compared to the broader equity market.

Valuation Metric	AutoNation (AN)	Lithia Motors (LAD)	Penske Auto. (PAG)	CarMax (KMX)
Market Cap ($B)	~$7.7B	~$7.7B	~$11.1B	~$8.5B
P/E Ratio (TTM)	9.8x – 12.0x	9.4x – 9.7x	11.5x – 12.0x	15.7x – 16.7x
EV/EBITDA (TTM)	9.6x – 10.9x	11.3x – 11.5x	11.6x – 13.0x	23.8x – 27.0x
Price/Sales (TTM)	~0.27x	~0.22x	~0.37x	~0.30x
Price/Book (TTM)	~2.9x	~1.2x	~2.0x	~1.4x
Dividend Yield (%)	0.0%	~0.7% (est.)	~3.1%	0.0%

Relative Valuation Analysis

When compared to its direct peers in the franchised auto dealership space, AutoNation’s valuation appears to be broadly in line. It trades at a trailing P/E ratio of approximately 9.8x to 12.0x and an EV/EBITDA multiple of roughly 9.6x to 10.9x.²¹ Lithia Motors (LAD) trades at a slightly lower P/E multiple but a higher EV/EBITDA multiple, which is reflective of its higher degree of financial leverage.³⁹ Penske Automotive Group (PAG) often commands a slight valuation premium, potentially due to the market’s appreciation for its international diversification and its stable commercial truck leasing business.³⁹

The most significant valuation discrepancy is with CarMax (KMX), which focuses exclusively on the used vehicle market. CarMax consistently trades at a substantial premium to the franchised dealers, with a P/E ratio in the mid-teens and an EV/EBITDA multiple well above 20x.⁴⁵ This premium reflects its different business model, national brand recognition in the used-car space, and historically higher growth profile.

Historical Valuation & Sum-of-the-Parts

AutoNation currently appears to be trading within its typical historical valuation bands. The central question for investors is the sustainability of its current earnings base. If the record profitability of the post-pandemic era continues to normalize downwards toward pre-pandemic levels, the current valuation multiples may prove to be less attractive than they appear at first glance.

A sum-of-the-parts (SOTP) valuation framework could suggest that AutoNation’s consolidated valuation is understated. This approach would assign separate, more appropriate multiples to each of its distinct business lines. The highly stable and profitable After-Sales segment, for example, could arguably be valued at a multiple similar to that of an auto parts retailer like AutoZone, which is significantly higher than AutoNation’s current consolidated multiple. Similarly, the growing AutoNation Finance arm could be valued as a specialty finance company. This analytical framework suggests that the market may not be fully appreciating the value of the individual components within AutoNation’s diversified business model.

The company’s modest valuation, when viewed in conjunction with its aggressive share repurchase program, creates a particularly powerful mechanism for EPS accretion. AutoNation’s P/E ratio in the high single digits to low double digits represents a significant discount to the broader S&P 500 average.³⁴ A low P/E ratio corresponds to a high earnings yield (the inverse of the P/E). For instance, a P/E of 10x implies an earnings yield of 10%. When AutoNation repurchases its own stock, it is effectively making an investment that generates a return equal to this high earnings yield. Given that the company is deploying hundreds of millions of dollars annually into these highly accretive buybacks, it is creating a compounding effect on EPS growth that is largely independent of its underlying operational growth.⁷ As long as the company continues to generate strong free cash flow and the market continues to assign a low multiple to its stock, this financial engineering will remain a significant and reliable driver of shareholder value.

Financial Modeling Considerations

When constructing a financial model for AutoNation, analysts should focus on several key value drivers and conduct scenario analysis to account for the inherent uncertainties in the automotive retail market.

Key Value Drivers

• Same-Store Sales Growth: This is a critical metric for assessing the underlying health of the business. Particular attention should be paid to the growth rate of the high-margin After-Sales segment, as it is a primary driver of profitability and cash flow.
• Gross Margins: The trajectory of new and used vehicle gross profit per unit is arguably the most significant variable in any near-term forecast. Modeling the pace of normalization from post-pandemic peaks toward historical averages is crucial.
• SG&A as a Percentage of Gross Profit: This efficiency ratio measures management’s ability to control operating costs and leverage its scale. Improvements in this metric can have a substantial impact on operating margins.
• Pace of Share Repurchases: The rate at which the company reduces its share count through buybacks will be a major driver of EPS growth, independent of operational performance.
• Growth of AutoNation Finance: The model should incorporate assumptions for the pace of loan originations, the net interest margin earned on the loan portfolio, and an appropriate provision for credit losses.

Scenario Analysis

To capture a range of potential outcomes, financial models should include scenario planning based on different macroeconomic and industry conditions.

• Bull Case: This scenario might assume a mild recession, which would allow the After-Sales segment to demonstrate its defensive characteristics. It would also assume that interest rates decline, boosting vehicle affordability and sales volumes. In this scenario, AutoNation successfully integrates several accretive tuck-in acquisitions, and vehicle margins stabilize at a level structurally higher than the pre-pandemic average.
• Base Case: This scenario would model a continued, gradual slowing of the economy. New vehicle margins would revert closer to their historical averages, while the After-Sales segment would continue to grow in the mid-single digits. The pace of share repurchases would remain steady.
• Bear Case: This scenario would incorporate a sharp economic recession that significantly impacts demand for both new and used vehicles. It might also include higher-than-expected credit losses in the AutoNation Finance portfolio and increased pressure from OEMs that further erodes dealer margins.

Conclusion & Investment Thesis Synthesis

Strengths

• Market Leadership and Scale: As the largest U.S. automotive retailer, AutoNation possesses significant scale advantages in purchasing, marketing, and technology, which are difficult for smaller competitors to replicate in a consolidating industry.
• Diversified and Resilient Business Model: The company’s mix of revenue streams, particularly the highly profitable and counter-cyclical After-Sales segment, provides a stable cash flow base that mitigates the volatility of vehicle sales.
• Strong Free Cash Flow Generation: The business model has a proven track record of generating substantial free cash flow, which fuels its capital allocation strategy.
• Shareholder-Friendly Capital Allocation: Management has demonstrated a disciplined and aggressive approach to returning capital to shareholders, primarily through a large-scale share repurchase program that has been highly accretive to EPS.
• High Barriers to Entry: The OEM franchise system creates a formidable moat, protecting incumbent dealers from new competition in the sale of new vehicles.

Weaknesses

• High Cyclical Exposure: The company’s financial performance is intrinsically linked to the health of the broader economy and discretionary consumer spending, making it vulnerable to economic downturns.
• Significant Debt Load: AutoNation carries a substantial amount of debt on its balance sheet, which could become a significant risk in a prolonged period of weak demand or high interest rates.
• Sub-Par Customer Metrics: Publicly available data on customer satisfaction and employee culture indicates that AutoNation lags some of its key competitors, which could pose a long-term risk to brand loyalty and retention.⁴⁸
• Geographic Concentration: A majority of the company’s sales are concentrated in the Sunbelt states of Florida, California, and Texas, exposing it to regional economic risks.

Primary Bull Thesis

The primary investment thesis for AutoNation is that it is a best-in-class operator poised to leverage its scale and data advantages to continue consolidating the fragmented U.S. dealership market. The stable, high-margin cash flow from its defensive After-Sales business provides a reliable funding source for an aggressive and value-accretive share repurchase program, which can drive significant EPS growth even in a flat market. Strategic initiatives in digital retail (AutoNation Express) and in-house financing (AutoNation Finance) offer additional, durable levers for long-term growth. The current valuation appears to not fully reflect the quality, resilience, and shareholder-return potential of this diversified business model.

Primary Bear Thesis

The primary countervailing thesis is that the automotive retail industry is in the midst of a challenging peak-to-trough margin normalization cycle as the unprecedented tailwinds of the post-pandemic era fade. Persistently high interest rates and the potential for a broader economic downturn will continue to pressure vehicle affordability and sales volumes. At the same time, intensifying competition and the capital-intensive, multi-year transition to electric vehicles will compress long-term returns on invested capital for the entire industry. In such a scenario, the company’s high financial leverage could become a significant risk factor.

Critical Factors to Monitor

• Gross Profit Per Unit (GPU): The trend in new and used vehicle GPUs will be the most important near-term indicator of margin pressure. Investors should monitor this metric closely for signs of stabilization or further deterioration.
• After-Sales Same-Store Growth: The continued resilience and growth of this high-margin segment are critical to the investment thesis. Any significant slowdown would be a major concern.
• Share Repurchase Pace: The level of buyback activity serves as a key indicator of management’s confidence in the company’s valuation and its commitment to the stated capital allocation strategy.
• AutoNation Finance Performance: Key metrics to track include loan origination growth, net interest margin, and, most importantly, credit loss provisions and delinquency rates.
• Industry SAAR: The Seasonally Adjusted Annual Rate (SAAR) of U.S. vehicle sales remains a crucial barometer for the overall health of the industry and a key driver of AutoNation’s top-line performance.

Works cited

1. AutoNation, Inc. – AnnualReports.com, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/Company/autonation-inc
2. AUTONATION, INC. SEC 10-K Report – TradingView, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.tradingview.com/news/tradingview:0b327b184240d:0-autonation-inc-sec-10-k-report/
3. AUTONATION, INC. SEC 10-Q Report — TradingView News, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.tradingview.com/news/tradingview:a6ed1aebfeef6:0-autonation-inc-sec-10-q-report/
4. AutoNation Reports Second Quarter 2025 Results – PR Newswire, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/autonation-reports-second-quarter-2025-results-302513637.html
5. AutoNation, Inc. (AN) Q2 2025 Earnings Call Transcript | Seeking Alpha, accessed August 3, 2025, https://seekingalpha.com/article/4804540-autonation-inc-an-q2-2025-earnings-call-transcript
6. AN 8K Earnings Release 6/30/25 EX99.1, accessed August 3, 2025, https://s22.q4cdn.com/689426802/files/doc_earnings/2025/q2/earnings-result/Q2-2025-Earnings-Release.pdf
7. Financials – Quarterly Results – AutoNation, Inc. – Investor Relations, accessed August 3, 2025, https://investors.autonation.com/financials/quarterly-results/default.aspx
8. AutoNation, Inc. – SEC.gov, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/350698/000095014408001449/g11814e10vk.htm
9. Shifting gears in automotive retail – NIQ, accessed August 3, 2025, https://nielseniq.com/global/en/insights/analysis/2025/shifting-gears-in-automotive-retail/
10. Automotive Retail Market: Technological advancement 2032, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.maximizemarketresearch.com/market-report/automotive-retail-market/213615/
11. 2025 Cox Automotive Market Insights and Outlook – Cox Automotive …, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.coxautoinc.com/market-insights/2025-cox-automotive-market-insights-and-outlook/
12. Dealership Consolidation in 2025: Navigating Valuation Peaks and Strategic Shifts – AInvest, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.ainvest.com/news/dealership-consolidation-2025-navigating-valuation-peaks-strategic-shifts-2507/
13. The Power of Consolidation: How Dealership Mergers Are … – AInvest, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.ainvest.com/news/power-consolidation-dealership-mergers-reshaping-automotive-investment-landscapes-2507/
14. Car Dealership Consolidation: Industry Analysis & Trends – BofA Securities, accessed August 3, 2025, https://business.bofa.com/en-us/content/dealership-industry-consolidation.html
15. Report: While profit margins fall, dealership acquisitions continue to rise | Auto Remarketing, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.autoremarketing.com/ar/analysis/report-while-profit-margins-fall-dealership-acquisitions-continue-to-rise/
16. AutoNation Competitors and Similar Companies – Zippia, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.zippia.com/autonation-careers-1140/competitors/
17. AutoNation Inc Peers & Key Competitors – GlobalData, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.globaldata.com/company-profile/autonation-inc/competitors/
18. Top AutoNation Competitors and Alternatives | Craft.co, accessed August 3, 2025, https://craft.co/autonation/competitors
19. How Will Car Dealership Consolidation Impact Car Buyers? – Automoblog, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.automoblog.com/car-dealership-consolidation/
20. Autonation Inc Comparisons to its Competitors and Market Share …, accessed August 3, 2025, https://csimarket.com/stocks/compet_glance.php?code=AN
21. AutoNation (AN) Competitors and Alternatives 2025 – MarketBeat, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.marketbeat.com/stocks/NYSE/AN/competitors-and-alternatives/
22. AutoNation Reinvents Automotive Retailing with Enhanced and Personalized Digital Customer Experience, accessed August 3, 2025, https://investors.autonation.com/news-and-events/press-releases/press-release-details/2021/AutoNation-Reinvents-Automotive-Retailing-with-Enhanced-and-Personalized-Digital-Customer-Experience/default.aspx
23. AutoNation Reinvents Automotive Retailing with Enhanced and Personalized Digital Customer Experience – PR Newswire, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/autonation-reinvents-automotive-retailing-with-enhanced-and-personalized-digital-customer-experience-301221422.html
24. AutoNation, Inc. – Investor Relations, accessed August 3, 2025, https://investors.autonation.com/home/default.aspx
25. 2025 Automotive Retail Outlook: AI & Inventory Intelligence – Lotlinx, accessed August 3, 2025, https://lotlinx.com/2025-automotive-retail-outlook/
26. AutoNation’s Q2 Earnings Outperformance: A Blueprint for Dealership Sector Resilience, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.ainvest.com/news/autonation-q2-earnings-outperformance-blueprint-dealership-sector-resilience-2507/
27. AutoNation Reimagines Car Sales and Service with Pure Storage, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.purestorage.com/content/dam/pdf/en/case-studies/cs-autonation-reimagines-sales-service.pdf
28. 2025 Global Automotive Consumer Study | Deloitte US, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.deloitte.com/us/en/Industries/consumer/articles/global-automotive-consumer-study.html
29. 2025 Global Automotive Consumer Study – Deloitte, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.deloitte.com/global/en/Industries/automotive/perspectives/global-automotive-consumer-study.html
30. Earnings call transcript: AutoNation beats Q2 2025 expectations; stock rises – Investing.com, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.investing.com/news/transcripts/earnings-call-transcript-autonation-beats-q2-2025-expectations-stock-rises-93CH-4153990
31. AutoNation, Inc. (AN) Stock Analysis | Price, Returns, Financials & Key Metrics, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.marketsmojo.com/stocks-analysis/autonation-inc-1150741-207
32. News & Events – Press Releases – AutoNation, Inc. – Investor Relations, accessed August 3, 2025, https://investors.autonation.com/news-and-events/press-releases/default.aspx
33. Form 10-K – SEC.gov, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/350698/000119312511035910/d10k.htm
34. AutoNation (AN) Stock Statistics & Valuation Metrics – TipRanks.com, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.tipranks.com/stocks/an/statistics
35. AutoNation – 28 Year Dividend History | AN | MacroTrends, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AN/autonation/dividend-yield-history
36. AN Dividend History & Yield AutoNation Inc – Morningstar, accessed August 3, 2025, https://global.morningstar.com/en-nd/investments/stocks/0P000000LJ/dividends
37. AutoNation, Inc. dividends – Digrin, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.digrin.com/stocks/detail/AN/
38. AutoNation Inc. (via Public) / Proxy Statement (Form DEF 14A), accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.publicnow.com/view/1E50B24B3EA2E24260304E0991A02E667DF93AAC?1741776406
39. Lithia Motors (NYSE:LAD) Stock Valuation, Peer Comparison & Price Targets, accessed August 3, 2025, https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/retail/nyse-lad/lithia-motors/valuation
40. Is Lithia Motors, Inc.(LAD) Building Momentum? – AAII, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.aaii.com/investingideas/article/316123-is-lithia-motors-inclad-building-momentum
41. EV / EBITDA For Lithia Motors Inc (LAD) – Finbox, accessed August 3, 2025, https://finbox.com/NYSE:LAD/explorer/ev_to_ebitda_ltm/
42. Penske Automotive Group (PAG) Statistics & Valuation – Stock Analysis, accessed August 3, 2025, https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/pag/statistics/
43. Penske Automotive Group Inc (PAG) – Morningstar, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.morningstar.com/stocks/xnys/pag/quote
44. EV / EBITDA For Penske Automotive Group Inc (PAG) – Finbox, accessed August 3, 2025, https://finbox.com/NYSE:PAG/explorer/ev_to_ebitda_ltm/
45. CarMax (KMX) Statistics & Valuation – Stock Analysis, accessed August 3, 2025, https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/kmx/statistics/
46. KMX – Carmax PE ratio, current and historical analysis – FullRatio, accessed August 3, 2025, https://fullratio.com/stocks/nyse-kmx/pe-ratio
47. CarMax (NYSE:KMX) Stock Valuation, Peer Comparison & Price Targets – Simply Wall St, accessed August 3, 2025, https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/retail/nyse-kmx/carmax/valuation
48. AutoNation Competitors | Comparably, accessed August 3, 2025, https://www.comparably.com/companies/autonation/competitors