Company Overview & Business Model

RLI Corp. is a U.S.-based specialty insurance company that has established a long-standing reputation for disciplined underwriting and consistent profitability. The company operates through a diversified portfolio of property, casualty, and surety products, targeting niche markets that are often underserved by larger, standard-lines carriers. For the fiscal year ended December 31, 2024, RLI surpassed $2.0 billion in gross premiums written for the first time in its history, reflecting sustained growth across its core operations.¹

The company’s operations are organized into three primary segments, each contributing to its diversified revenue base.

• Casualty Segment: This is RLI’s largest segment by premium volume. It offers a broad range of liability coverages, including general liability for commercial insureds like manufacturers and contractors, environmental liability for risks such as pollution, and both commercial and personal umbrella policies that provide excess liability protection.² In 2024, the Casualty segment reported a robust 15% increase in gross premiums written. This growth was fueled by a combination of rate increases across a significant portion of its book and strong new business generation within its personal umbrella and small commercial distribution channels.¹
• Property Segment: This segment focuses on providing coverage for specialized property risks that often fall outside the appetite of standard insurers. Key product lines include commercial property, marine insurance, and coverage for catastrophe-exposed properties like those in Hawaii.³ Despite significant natural catastrophe activity, the Property segment grew gross premiums written by 7% in 2024, driven by necessary rate increases and a healthy flow of new business opportunities.¹
• Surety Segment: The Surety segment provides financial guarantees for the performance of contractual and commercial obligations. These products are critical for industries like construction, where performance bonds are often required. In 2024, this segment achieved a 9% increase in gross premiums written, benefiting from favorable economic conditions that spurred construction and commercial activity, as well as an expansion of the company’s producer partnerships.¹

RLI strategically operates in both the specialty admitted and the excess and surplus (E&S) insurance markets. In 2024, specialty admitted operations accounted for approximately 57% of total gross premiums written. The E&S market, which represented 42% of gross premiums, is a crucial component of RLI’s strategy. This market allows the company to underwrite non-standard, hard-to-place risks with more flexible policy forms and unregulated premium rates, enabling it to craft bespoke solutions for complex exposures.⁴ A minor portion of its business, around 1% in 2024, is derived from the specialty reinsurance market.⁴

Underwriting Philosophy and Risk Management

The cornerstone of RLI’s business model and its most significant differentiating factor is an unwavering, deeply ingrained underwriting philosophy that prioritizes profitability over top-line growth. This culture is consistently articulated by management, who have stated, “We do not have top line goals at our line,” and is reinforced by an incentive structure that rewards underwriters for maximizing underwriting profit, even at the expense of shrinking premium volume in unfavorable market conditions.¹ This disciplined approach is not a recent development; it has enabled the company to achieve an underwriting profit in 28 consecutive years through 2023, a remarkable feat in the cyclical insurance industry.⁵

This philosophy is supported by a comprehensive, enterprise-wide risk management framework that addresses the multifaceted risks inherent in the insurance business.

• Disciplined Risk Selection: RLI avoids competing on price, focusing instead on markets where its expertise in underwriting, claims handling, and service can create a competitive advantage. The company has a history of exiting markets when pricing becomes irrational or adverse and entering new niches where it can achieve profitable risk transfer.¹
• Catastrophe Exposure Management: The company actively manages its exposure to catastrophic events by quantifying policy limits in vulnerable regions, utilizing sophisticated computer-assisted modeling techniques, and purchasing reinsurance to reduce the financial impact of any single large event.¹
• Conservative Reserving: RLI establishes loss reserves based on a rigorous process that incorporates historical data, actuarial analysis, and projections of future trends in claim frequency and severity. The company’s history of favorable development on prior years’ loss reserves, including a $24.4 million net positive impact on underwriting income in the second quarter of 2025, serves as validation of its conservative and prudent reserving practices.⁶
• High-Quality Investment Portfolio: The investment strategy is conservative, prioritizing the preservation of capital to ensure the company can meet its obligations to policyholders at all times. The secondary goal is to grow book value through a total return approach focused on a diversified portfolio of high-quality, marketable securities.¹

The company’s business model is intentionally dynamic and opportunistic rather than static. Management has demonstrated a willingness to strategically shrink or grow its presence in various segments based on prevailing market conditions. This flexibility is evident in its recent strategy of pulling back from the highly competitive E&S property market while simultaneously pushing for significant rate increases and pursuing selective growth in liability lines with “wheels based exposures”.³ This ability to pivot capital and underwriting resources toward the most attractive opportunities within the insurance cycle is a key element of its long-term success.

Industry Dynamics & Market Position

RLI operates within the specialty segment of the broader property and casualty (P&C) insurance industry. This market is characterized by unique risks that require specialized underwriting expertise and tailored policy language, differentiating it from the more commoditized standard insurance market.

The Specialty Insurance Market Landscape

The specialty insurance market is undergoing a period of robust growth and significant evolution. The market is projected to expand from approximately $142 billion in 2024 to nearly $279 billion by 2031, outpacing the growth of standard insurance lines.⁸ This expansion is being driven by several powerful, secular trends.

• Emerging and Complex Risks: The risk landscape is becoming increasingly complex. Climate change is contributing to a higher frequency and severity of natural disasters, such as hurricanes and wildfires. This is causing standard insurers to restrict coverage or withdraw from high-risk areas, creating a significant opportunity for specialty carriers to provide solutions.⁸ Concurrently, the rapid digitization of the economy has made cyber risk a primary concern for businesses of all sizes, with the cyber insurance market expected to double in size over the next decade.⁸
• Technological Transformation: Technology, particularly artificial intelligence (AI), is fundamentally reshaping the insurance value chain. Insurers are leveraging AI to enhance underwriting by rapidly analyzing submissions and integrating third-party data, to improve claims processing through automated damage assessment, and to detect fraud more effectively.⁸ A recent survey found that 99% of insurers are either currently investing in or planning to invest in generative AI capabilities, indicating a broad industry-wide commitment to technological advancement.¹⁰
• Bifurcated Pricing Cycle: The P&C insurance market is currently experiencing a bifurcated pricing cycle. After several years of broad-based rate increases (a “hard market”), conditions are now diverging significantly by line of business. The commercial property market has seen an influx of new capital and increased competition, leading to rate softening and more challenging underwriting conditions.³ In contrast, casualty lines—particularly commercial auto, umbrella, and excess liability—continue to experience significant rate hardening. This is driven by persistent loss-cost inflation, rising repair costs, and the phenomenon of “social inflation,” where larger jury awards and more aggressive litigation drive up the cost of liability claims.¹¹ Data from the second quarter of 2025 shows that while global commercial insurance rates declined by 4% on average, casualty rates increased by 4%, led by a sharp 9% rise in the U.S. market.¹²

RLI’s Competitive Positioning & Moat

RLI has carved out a strong position within this dynamic market by focusing on niches where it can leverage its expertise rather than competing on scale or price. Its competitive moat is not built on being the largest carrier but on a set of qualitative and cultural advantages that are difficult for rivals to replicate. The company’s primary competitors are other large, well-capitalized specialty insurers, with the specific competitive set varying by segment.¹³

• Casualty Competitors: Arch, Chubb, Markel, Travelers, and Zurich.¹³
• Property Competitors: Arch, Chubb, Lexington, and Travelers.¹³
• Surety Competitors: AIG, Arch, Chubb, Travelers, and XL.¹³

RLI’s durable competitive advantages include:

• Superior Underwriting Expertise: The company’s most significant advantage is its decades of specialized knowledge in its chosen markets. This deep expertise creates a formidable barrier to entry and is the primary driver of its consistent, long-term underwriting profitability. The clearest evidence of this is its 10-year average statutory combined ratio of 88.5, which has outperformed the P&C industry average of 100.2 by a remarkable 12 percentage points.¹
• Exceptional Financial Strength: RLI’s balance sheet is a key competitive tool. The company holds an A+ (Superior) financial strength rating from AM Best, which recently revised its outlook on the company to positive, and an A (Strong) rating from S&P.⁵ These high ratings provide confidence to brokers and policyholders that RLI will be able to meet its claims obligations, which is a critical factor in the selection of an insurance partner.
• Unique Ownership Culture: RLI fosters a strong ownership culture through its Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP). By making employees owners of the company, the ESOP aligns their interests directly with those of external shareholders, promoting a shared sense of accountability and a focus on long-term, sustainable value creation.¹

The current market environment, with its diverging pricing trends, presents both a challenge and an opportunity for RLI. The company’s disciplined model is being tested in the softening property market, where it has been forced to shed premium to maintain its profitability standards. However, this same discipline positions it well to capitalize on the hard casualty market, where its ability to accurately price risk and achieve necessary rate increases is a significant advantage. This demonstrates that RLI’s strategy allows it to react rationally to market signals, even if it results in short-term top-line volatility.

Financial Performance & Health

RLI’s financial track record is distinguished by its consistency and profitability. The company’s financial statements reflect the successful execution of its disciplined underwriting and conservative investment philosophies over an extended period.

A Decade of Profitability

An analysis of RLI’s performance over the last ten years reveals a pattern of steady growth and superior returns. The company has consistently grown its premium base while maintaining underwriting margins that are significantly better than the industry average. This has translated into strong earnings and a consistent compounding of shareholder value, as measured by book value per share.

Table 1: RLI Historical Financial Summary (2015-2024)

Year	Gross Premiums Written (in thousands)	GAAP Combined Ratio	Net Earnings (in thousands)	Diluted EPS	Book Value Per Share	Return on Equity
2024	$2,013,048	86.2%	$345,779	$3.74	$16.59	22.2%
2023	$1,806,660	86.6%	$304,611	$3.31	$15.49	23.3%
2022	$1,643,533	84.4%	$610,600*	$13.23*	$12.95	49.1%*
2021	$1,371,289	89.0%	$285,100	$6.21	$13.57	21.0%
2020	$1,114,941	96.2%	$140,500	$3.09	$12.58	11.8%
2019	$1,023,732	94.0%	$292,300	$6.45	$11.09	28.5%
2018	$904,008	91.1%	$140,300	$3.12	$9.06	14.8%
2017	$838,620	91.8%	$159,000	$3.55	$9.67	15.9%
2016	$793,663	85.3%	$146,000	$3.27	$9.37	15.0%
2015	$751,219	83.2%	$143,400	$3.22	$9.46	14.9%
Note: 2022 Net Earnings, Diluted EPS, and Return on Equity were significantly impacted by a one-time pre-tax gain of $434.4 million ($9.49 per diluted share) from the sale of the company’s investment in Maui Jim, Inc..5 Data sourced from RLI’s 2023 and 2024 Annual Reports.1 All per-share data is retroactively adjusted for the January 2025 stock split.4

Segment Performance and Recent Results

While the long-term picture is one of stability, a closer look at recent segment performance reveals the dynamic nature of RLI’s response to the current market. The first half of 2025 highlights the diverging trends in the property and casualty markets.

Table 2: Segment Performance Breakdown (Six Months Ended June 30)

Metric	Casualty	Property	Surety	Total
Gross Premiums Written (in thousands)
2025	$668,500	$346,500	$105,000	$1,120,000
2024	$624,766	$385,000	$98,130	$1,107,896
% Change	+7.0%	-10.0%	+7.0%	+1.1%
Combined Ratio
2025	96.5	62.1	87.9	84.5
2024	95.1	60.3	81.8	81.5
Note: Data is derived from Q2 2025 earnings releases and management commentary. Gross premiums written are estimated based on stated growth percentages from management commentary.3 Combined ratios are as reported for the second quarter.7

This data starkly illustrates the company’s current strategic posture: accepting a 10% contraction in the highly competitive property segment to protect underwriting margins, while capitalizing on the hard market in casualty and surety to achieve 7% growth in both of those segments.³ Despite the top-line pressures, all three segments remained profitable on an underwriting basis in the second quarter of 2025.³

Investment Portfolio and Balance Sheet Strength

RLI’s financial health is further reinforced by a conservative balance sheet and a well-managed investment portfolio.

• Investment Income: The portfolio serves as a significant and growing contributor to earnings. Net investment income increased by 18% in 2024 and by another 16.1% in the second quarter of 2025, driven by higher reinvestment rates on the company’s strong operating cash flows.¹
• Capital Adequacy: The company maintains a strong capital position with low financial leverage. As of June 30, 2025, RLI had total shareholders’ equity of $1.73 billion against only $100 million in debt, resulting in a very conservative debt-to-equity ratio.¹⁵ This financial strength is a key factor supporting its A+ rating from AM Best.⁵
• Cash Flow: The business consistently generates robust cash from operations, which provides the capital for both investment and shareholder returns. Operating cash flow rose 23.2% to $174.7 million in the second quarter of 2025.¹⁶

The company’s financial model can be viewed as a self-reinforcing cycle. Disciplined underwriting generates consistent profits and strong operating cash flow. This cash is then invested in a conservative portfolio that produces a steady stream of investment income. The combination of underwriting and investment profits drives growth in book value and strengthens the balance sheet, which in turn supports the high financial strength ratings necessary to attract and retain profitable business, thus perpetuating the cycle.

Recent Challenges & Industry Headwinds (2023-2025)

Despite its strong long-term track record, RLI is currently navigating a complex and challenging operating environment. The period from 2023 through 2025 has been marked by significant headwinds in certain key markets, testing the company’s underwriting discipline and impacting its near-term growth trajectory.

Segment-Specific Challenges

The most pressing challenges are concentrated in the company’s two largest segments, Property and Casualty, where opposing market forces are at play.

• Property Segment Contraction: The most significant headwind facing RLI is the intense competition and rate softening in the E&S property market. An influx of capital and the entry of approximately 20 new competitors over the last two years have created an environment of aggressive pricing.³ True to its philosophy, RLI has chosen not to compete on price where it believes the risk-reward profile is inadequate. This has resulted in a deliberate contraction of this business line, with gross premiums written declining by 10% in the second quarter of 2025.³ This strategic pullback, while protective of long-term profitability, has been the primary cause of the company’s recent flat overall top-line growth, which has drawn scrutiny from the market.¹⁷
• Casualty Loss Cost Pressures: While the casualty market is experiencing rate hardening, which is a positive for revenue growth, the segment is simultaneously grappling with significant loss-cost inflation.¹⁷ Both general economic inflation and “social inflation”—characterized by more aggressive litigation and larger jury awards—are driving up the ultimate cost of claims, particularly for commercial auto and transportation lines.³ The company’s casualty accident year loss ratio in the fourth quarter of 2024 was higher than internal projections, signaling the intensity of these pressures.¹⁷ In response, management has been aggressively pursuing rate increases, achieving an average of 14% on auto coverages in the second quarter of 2025, and tightening its underwriting standards to mitigate the impact of rising claims severity.³

Macroeconomic and Market Factors

Broader economic forces have also had a mixed impact on RLI’s operations and financial results.

• Interest Rate Environment: The rise in interest rates from 2022 through 2023 has been a net benefit for RLI. The ability to reinvest its substantial operating cash flow into higher-yielding fixed-income securities has provided a significant boost to net investment income. This income stream grew by 40% in 2023 and has continued to show double-digit growth in 2025, providing a reliable source of earnings that helps offset underwriting volatility.⁵
• Inflation: While higher interest rates have been beneficial for the investment portfolio, persistent inflation has been a direct headwind for the underwriting side of the business. Inflation increases the cost of everything from auto parts and medical care to construction materials, directly impacting the cost to settle claims and putting upward pressure on loss ratios.¹¹ This makes achieving adequate pricing a critical and ongoing challenge.
• Catastrophe Losses: RLI’s business model carries inherent exposure to natural catastrophes. While this is a managed risk, large events can still have a material impact on quarterly or annual results. In 2023, the company absorbed the largest net catastrophe loss in its history as a result of the devastating wildfires in Hawaii, a stark reminder of the volatility inherent in its property book.⁵

The current environment serves as a real-world stress test of RLI’s foundational principle of prioritizing profitability over growth. The decision to shrink the property book in the face of irrational pricing is a classic example of this discipline in action. However, this has created a clear divergence between the company’s long-term strategy and the market’s short-term focus on revenue growth, as evidenced by the negative stock price reaction to the second quarter 2025 earnings report despite an EPS beat.³ Consequently, the company’s ability to successfully secure adequate rate increases in its large Casualty segment to offset both inflationary pressures and the revenue decline in Property has become the most critical variable for its near-term earnings performance.

Growth Opportunities & Strategic Initiatives

While navigating the current headwinds, RLI is also pursuing several avenues for future growth, grounded in its core competencies of specialized underwriting and disciplined market expansion. The company’s strategy is focused on organic growth in targeted niches rather than large-scale acquisitions or aggressive market share grabs.

Key Growth Drivers

• Surety Segment Expansion: The Surety segment has consistently been a source of strength and profitable growth for RLI, exceeding expectations in recent periods.¹⁷ The company is actively investing in this franchise. It recently renewed and expanded its reinsurance treaty, which increases its capacity to offer larger bonds and support the growing needs of its contractor clients.³ Management is also leveraging new digital tools to make it easier for producers to do business with RLI, helping to win new accounts. This segment is also poised to benefit from potential long-term tailwinds related to increased government infrastructure spending, which would drive demand for performance bonds.¹⁷
• Selective Growth in Casualty: Despite the well-documented loss-cost pressures, the hard market conditions in many casualty lines present a significant opportunity for a disciplined underwriter like RLI. As some competitors may struggle with profitability or pull back capacity, RLI can leverage its strong balance sheet and underwriting expertise to selectively write more business at attractive rates.¹⁷ The 24% growth in its personal umbrella product in the second quarter of 2025 is a prime example of this strategy in action, demonstrating the company’s ability to identify and capitalize on profitable niches within the broader segment.³
• Long-Term Opportunities in Emerging Markets: The broader specialty insurance market continues to evolve, creating demand for new types of coverage. Growth areas such as cyber insurance, risk management for renewable energy projects, and liability coverage for new technologies represent long-term expansion opportunities.¹⁹ RLI’s expertise-driven business model, which is built on entering and mastering complex underwriting niches, is structurally well-suited to methodically expand into these emerging risk categories over time.

Strategic Initiatives

RLI’s strategic initiatives are focused on enhancing its existing capabilities and strengthening its competitive advantages.

• Technology and Digital Transformation: The company is making targeted investments in technology aimed at improving the customer and producer experience. These initiatives include enhancements to its digital platforms and customer relationship management (CRM) systems, which are designed to streamline underwriting processes and strengthen distribution relationships.³ While RLI’s absolute spending on technology may be less than that of its much larger competitors, these focused investments are intended to improve operational efficiency and solidify its market position.¹⁹
• Acquisition Strategy: RLI’s growth has been overwhelmingly organic. The company’s history of acquisitions is very limited, with its most recent notable transaction being the purchase of a small specialty agency in 2016.²⁰ This indicates a clear strategic preference for building expertise internally and growing deliberately, rather than pursuing growth through large, potentially disruptive M&A activity.

Overall, RLI’s approach to growth is consistent with its broader corporate philosophy: it is deliberate, organic, and focused on niches where it has a demonstrable and sustainable competitive advantage. Investors should therefore anticipate a strategy of steady, profitable compounding rather than one aimed at explosive, transformational growth.

Capital Allocation & Shareholder Returns

RLI’s capital allocation strategy is a defining feature of its investment profile and is characterized by a clear and consistent focus on returning capital to shareholders. The company employs a multi-pronged approach that combines a steadily growing regular dividend with a policy of paying out excess capital through substantial special dividends.

Dividend Policy and History

RLI has one of the most impressive dividend track records in the entire U.S. stock market.

• Regular Dividend: As of February 2025, the company has increased its regular quarterly dividend for 50 consecutive years.¹⁴ This achievement places RLI in the elite group of companies known as “Dividend Kings.” The regular dividend is managed conservatively to ensure its sustainability through all phases of the insurance cycle. The most recently declared regular dividend was $0.16 per share.²¹
• Special Dividends: A core and unique component of RLI’s capital return policy is its consistent use of special dividends to return capital that is not needed to support business growth. The company has paid a special dividend in each of the last 14 years.⁵ These payments can be very significant and often represent a much larger portion of the total annual cash return to shareholders than the regular dividend. For example, RLI paid a $2.00 per share special dividend in December 2023 and a $4.00 per share special dividend in November 2024.¹
  (Note: There is a discrepancy in the 2024 special dividend amount between the 2024 Annual Report, which states $2.00, and the company’s dividend history page, which shows a $4.00 payment. The dividend history page is likely more accurate as it reflects the actual declaration.)

Over the last decade, the combination of regular and special dividends has resulted in RLI returning nearly $1.5 billion in cash to its shareholders.¹

Share Repurchase Programs

In contrast to its robust dividend policy, RLI does not appear to utilize share repurchases as a significant tool for capital return. The company’s 2024 annual report explicitly states “Issuer Purchases of Equity Securities – Not applicable,” indicating the absence of an active buyback program during that period.¹

Capital Allocation Priorities

Management’s actions and policies reveal a clear and disciplined hierarchy for capital allocation:

1. Reinvest in the Business: The first priority is to retain sufficient capital to support organic growth opportunities within the insurance operations and to maintain the company’s strong balance sheet and superior financial strength ratings.
2. Pay a Growing Regular Dividend: The second priority is to fund the stable and consistently growing regular quarterly dividend, continuing its 50-year streak of increases.
3. Return Excess Capital via Special Dividends: Any capital remaining after the first two priorities are met is deemed excess and is returned to shareholders directly through a large, variable special dividend.

This strategy demonstrates a strong belief that returning cash directly to the company’s owners is the most efficient use of capital once the needs of the business have been fully met. The special dividend functions as a flexible “release valve” for the company’s annual profitability. In years of strong underwriting and investment performance, the special dividend is large; in more challenging years, it is smaller. This makes the total dividend yield highly variable and directly links the shareholder’s annual cash return to the company’s operational success.

Management Quality & Corporate Governance

The quality of a company’s leadership and the robustness of its governance framework are critical factors in its long-term success. RLI appears to have a stable, experienced management team and corporate governance practices that are well-aligned with shareholder interests.

Management Team and Track Record

RLI’s executive team is characterized by experience and a long tenure with the company, which is consistent with the firm’s stable, long-term strategic orientation. The leadership’s execution capabilities are best evidenced by the company’s exceptional long-term financial performance. The multi-decade streaks of underwriting profitability and consecutive dividend increases are direct testaments to the management team’s consistent and disciplined execution of the company’s core business strategy.⁵

Corporate Governance Practices

RLI has implemented several best practices in corporate governance that promote effective oversight and alignment with shareholder interests.

• Board Structure and Independence: The roles of Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive Officer have been separated since January 1, 2022, a governance practice that enhances board independence and oversight.²³ The board is composed of ten director nominees, nine of whom are classified as independent, ensuring that oversight is not unduly influenced by management.²³ Furthermore, all directors are elected annually, which provides shareholders with a regular and direct mechanism for holding the board accountable.²³
• Shareholder Alignment and Communication: The company actively seeks shareholder feedback on key issues. Its annual meeting agenda includes an advisory “Say-on-Pay” vote, which allows shareholders to voice their opinion on the structure and quantum of executive compensation.²³ The company’s strong ownership culture, which is fostered by its Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP), further aligns the interests of employees with those of external shareholders, creating a powerful incentive for all stakeholders to focus on long-term value creation.¹

The combination of an experienced management team with a proven track record and a robust governance structure featuring an independent board provides a strong foundation for the company’s continued stability and disciplined operation. This framework is a crucial, though often overlooked, component supporting RLI’s reliable long-term performance.

Risk Assessment

An investment in RLI Corp. is subject to a variety of risks inherent in the property and casualty insurance industry, as well as risks specific to its business model and market focus. These risks are detailed in the company’s regulatory filings and are critical for any potential investor to understand.¹

Key Business Risks

• Underwriting and Reserving Risk: The most fundamental risk for any insurer is the possibility that the premiums it collects will be insufficient to cover the ultimate cost of claims. This can happen through either mispricing risk at the outset or through inadequate reserving for future claim payments. RLI’s loss reserves are based on complex estimates that are inherently uncertain. If actual losses exceed reserved amounts, the company’s future profitability would be materially and adversely affected.¹
• Catastrophe Risk: As an insurer of property, RLI has significant exposure to unpredictable and potentially severe losses from natural catastrophes such as hurricanes, earthquakes, and wildfires. A single large event or a series of events in a given year could cause substantial financial losses and significant volatility in the company’s earnings.¹
• Reinsurance Risk: RLI cedes a portion of its risk to reinsurance companies to limit its maximum potential loss. This strategy exposes RLI to two primary forms of reinsurance risk: the credit risk that a reinsurer may be unable or unwilling to pay its share of claims, and the market risk that reinsurance may become unavailable or prohibitively expensive, forcing RLI to retain more risk or reduce its business volume.¹
• Competition and Cyclicality: The P&C insurance industry is intensely competitive and highly cyclical. During “soft” market phases, intense competition can drive down premium rates to unprofitable levels. RLI’s discipline may force it to shed business in such an environment, impacting its revenue. This risk is currently manifesting in the commercial property market.¹

Concentration Risks

RLI’s business model also entails specific concentration risks.

• Geographic Concentration: A significant portion of the company’s direct premium is concentrated in a few key states. In 2024, 57% of direct premiums were derived from Florida (20%), California (18%), Texas (11%), and New York (8%).¹ This concentration makes the company’s results disproportionately vulnerable to adverse changes in the legal, regulatory, or catastrophic event landscape in these specific states.
• Broker Concentration: In 2024, 46% of RLI’s premium revenues were generated through a small number of key brokers and carrier partners. The loss of a major distribution relationship could have a material adverse effect on the company’s ability to source new business.¹

Operational and Macroeconomic Risks

• Cybersecurity: As a financial institution that handles sensitive data, RLI is a target for cybersecurity attacks. A significant breach could lead to operational disruptions, financial losses, regulatory penalties, and reputational damage.¹
• Economic Sensitivity: Demand for many of RLI’s products, particularly in the Surety and Casualty segments, is tied to the health of the broader economy. A significant economic downturn could lead to reduced construction activity and lower corporate revenues, which would in turn reduce demand for insurance and negatively impact RLI’s revenue and profitability.¹

Among this broad set of risks, the most acute threats to the investment thesis in the near term are the cyclical pressures currently impacting the property market and the ever-present risk of a major catastrophe in one of its key states. The competitive dynamics in the property market are not a theoretical risk; they are actively causing a contraction in a major business line. Similarly, the company’s experience with the 2023 Hawaiian wildfires demonstrates that the geographic concentration risk can and does translate into material financial losses.⁵

Valuation Analysis

The valuation of RLI Corp. reflects the market’s recognition of its superior profitability and consistent performance. The company has historically traded at a premium to the broader property and casualty insurance industry, and a comprehensive valuation analysis requires comparing its current metrics to both its own historical ranges and to those of its closest peers.

Historical Valuation Context

• Price-to-Earnings (P/E) Ratio: RLI’s P/E ratio has exhibited significant volatility, influenced by both its stock price and the cyclicality of its earnings. As of August 2025, the company’s P/E ratio stood at 19.57. This is slightly below its 12-month average of 20.87 but remains above its 3-year and 5-year historical averages of 16.9 and 18.49, respectively.²⁵ This suggests that while the valuation has come down from recent peaks, it is still elevated compared to its medium-term history.
• Price-to-Book (P/B) Ratio: The P/B ratio is a critical valuation metric for insurers, as book value represents the net assets available to generate future earnings. As of August 2025, RLI’s P/B ratio was approximately 3.5 to 3.6.²⁶ This is below the peak of 4.95 reached at the end of 2024 but is consistent with the premium valuation the company has sustained over the past several years.²⁶

Peer Group Benchmarking

Comparing RLI’s valuation to that of its specialty insurance peers provides essential context. The analysis reveals that RLI occupies a distinct valuation tier, reflecting its unique blend of consistent profitability and moderate growth.

Table 3: Peer Valuation Comparison (as of August 2025)

Company (Ticker)	Market Cap (USD)	P/E Ratio (TTM)	P/B Ratio (Current)	Return on Equity (TTM)	Dividend Yield (Fwd, Regular)
RLI Corp. (RLI)	$6.2 B	19.6	3.60	16.1%	0.95%
Arch Capital Group (ACGL)	$34.3 B	9.5	1.55	18.5%	0.00%
Kinsale Capital Group (KNSL)	$10.6 B	23.5	6.25	28.7%	0.15%
W. R. Berkley Corp. (WRB)	$27.0 B	16.2	2.93	20.6%	2.27%*
Note: WRB’s dividend yield includes special dividends in its calculation by some sources. The regular yield is lower. Data sourced from a compilation of market data providers.21

This comparison yields several important observations:

• Premium to Traditional Peers: RLI trades at a substantial valuation premium to larger, more diversified peers like Arch Capital and W. R. Berkley on both P/E and, most notably, P/B metrics. RLI’s P/B ratio is more than double that of Arch Capital.
• Discount to High-Growth Peers: In contrast, RLI is valued at a significant discount to Kinsale Capital Group, a high-growth E&S specialist. Kinsale’s P/B ratio of over 6.25 reflects the market’s high expectations for its future growth, which has historically been much faster than RLI’s.

The market is consistently willing to pay a higher multiple for each dollar of RLI’s book value compared to most peers. This premium is fundamentally justified by the company’s long-term, structurally superior profitability. RLI’s consistent ability to generate a high return on equity (ROE) and maintain an industry-leading combined ratio provides the basis for this valuation. The market is essentially pricing in the expectation that RLI’s management will continue to be a more profitable steward of shareholder capital than the average insurer.

Dividend Yield Attractiveness

On the surface, RLI’s forward dividend yield of approximately 0.95%, based solely on its regular dividend, appears unattractive.²¹ However, this metric is highly misleading. The company’s primary method of cash return is its large, annual special dividend. When these payments are included, the total shareholder yield is substantially higher and more representative of the actual cash return. For example, some sources calculate an all-in yield of 3.85% based on recent total payments.³⁸ This total yield is competitive, but investors must be comfortable with its variability, as the size of the special dividend is directly dependent on the company’s annual performance.

Key Questions to Address

This comprehensive analysis of RLI Corp. can be synthesized to address several key questions that are central to an investment thesis.

• What differentiates RLI from other specialty insurers?
  RLI’s primary differentiator is not what it does, but how it does it. Its most defining characteristic is a deeply ingrained, 50-year-old corporate culture that unequivocally prioritizes underwriting profit over top-line growth. This philosophy, reinforced by an employee ownership structure, manifests in a structurally superior combined ratio and a remarkable 28-year streak of underwriting profitability. This is complemented by a unique capital return policy that favors large, variable special dividends, directly sharing annual profits with shareholders.
• How sustainable are RLI’s competitive advantages?
  The company’s core competitive advantages—its specialized underwriting expertise and its disciplined culture—are qualitative and have proven to be highly sustainable over multiple decades. These advantages are difficult for competitors to replicate, as they are built on accumulated knowledge and institutional habit rather than on scale or price. However, these advantages do not make RLI immune to severe, cyclical market pressures. The current challenges in the property market demonstrate that even a disciplined underwriter must sometimes sacrifice revenue to maintain its standards, highlighting a practical limit to its ability to grow in all market conditions.
• What are the most significant risks to the investment thesis?
  The most significant risks can be categorized into three areas:

1. Cyclical Market Risk: A prolonged and deep soft market in a major segment, such as the current situation in property, could force a difficult choice between abandoning underwriting standards to maintain market share or accepting a significant and sustained decline in revenue, which could de-rate the stock’s valuation multiple.
2. Catastrophe Risk: Given the company’s significant geographic concentration in catastrophe-prone states like Florida and California, a single mega-catastrophe event could generate losses that overwhelm its reinsurance protection and cause a material impairment of book value.
3. Execution Risk: The investment thesis relies on continued superior execution. A failure to keep pricing ahead of accelerating loss-cost trends in the large Casualty segment would compress underwriting margins and call into question the very expertise for which the company commands a premium valuation.

• How well-positioned is RLI for the current insurance cycle?
  RLI is defensively and rationally positioned for the current bifurcated cycle. It is leveraging its underwriting discipline to avoid unprofitable competition in the softening property market while using its expertise to push for necessary rate increases in the hardening casualty market. This posture may lead to muted or flat overall top-line growth in the near term, which could create a headwind for the stock price. However, it is the correct strategic approach to protect long-term profitability and book value growth, fully consistent with the company’s historical model.
• What catalysts could drive future outperformance or underperformance?
• Potential Catalysts for Underperformance:

• A failure to achieve rate increases in the Casualty segment that are adequate to offset loss-cost inflation.
• A major hurricane making landfall in Florida or another significant catastrophe in a key state.
• A further deterioration in the property market that forces a larger-than-anticipated contraction in revenue for an extended period.
• Potential Catalysts for Outperformance:

• A cyclical turn in the property market, allowing RLI to profitably grow its premium base in that segment once again.
• Continued strong growth and profitability in the Surety segment, potentially boosted by infrastructure spending.
• Better-than-expected success in managing casualty loss costs, leading to margin expansion.
• The declaration of a particularly large special dividend at year-end, driven by strong overall underwriting and investment results, which would highlight the cash-generative nature of the business model.

Works cited

1. RLI CORP. ANNUAL REPORT ON FORM 10K, accessed August 28, 2025, https://s204.q4cdn.com/949661285/files/doc_financials/2024/ar/RLI-2024-ARS-Final.pdf
2. RLI Corp. – AnnualReports.com, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/Company/rli-corp
3. Earnings call transcript: RLI Corp Q2 2025 sees mixed earnings …, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.investing.com/news/transcripts/earnings-call-transcript-rli-corp-q2-2025-sees-mixed-earnings-results-93CH-4146567
4. RLI CORP., accessed August 28, 2025, https://s204.q4cdn.com/949661285/files/doc_financials/2024/q4/01171a60-4ebd-4a75-9b9e-98c880633730.pdf
5. RLI CORP. ANNUAL REPORT ON FORM 10K – SEC.gov, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/84246/000155837024001619/rli-20231231xars.pdf
6. RLI Reports Second Quarter 2025 Results, accessed August 28, 2025, https://investors.rlicorp.com/news/news-details/2025/RLI-Reports-Second-Quarter-2025-Results/default.aspx
7. Financials – Quarterly Results – RLI Corp – Investor relations, accessed August 28, 2025, https://investors.rlicorp.com/financials/quarterly-results/default.aspx
8. Key Trends in Specialty Insurance in 2025 and Beyond | Innoveo, accessed August 28, 2025, https://innoveo.com/blog/key-trends-in-specialty-insurance-in-2025-and-beyond/
9. Specialty Insurance Market 2025 – Share And Growth to 2034, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.thebusinessresearchcompany.com/report/specialty-insurance-global-market-report
10. 2024 Insurance Year in Review and 2025 Developments – IRMI, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.irmi.com/articles/expert-commentary/2024-insurance-year-in-review-and-2025-developments
11. State of the Insurance Market – Casualty | Q4 2024 -2025 – Risk Strategies, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.risk-strategies.com/state-of-the-insurance-market-report-2024-casualty
12. Global Insurance Market Index 2025 – Marsh, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.marsh.com/en/services/international-placement-services/insights/global-insurance-market-index.html
13. About us – CSIMarket.com, accessed August 28, 2025, https://csimarket.com/stocks/compet_glance.php?code=RLI
14. News – RLI Corp – Investor relations, accessed August 28, 2025, https://investors.rlicorp.com/news/default.aspx
15. UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION …, accessed August 28, 2025, https://s204.q4cdn.com/949661285/files/doc_financials/2025/q2/10q-RLI.pdf
16. RLI Delivers 20% Revenue Growth in Q2 – Nasdaq, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/rli-delivers-20-revenue-growth-q2
17. RLI’s SWOT analysis: insurance firm’s stock faces growth challenges …, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.investing.com/news/swot-analysis/rlis-swot-analysis-insurance-firms-stock-faces-growth-challenges-93CH-4194301
18. RLI’s SWOT analysis: insurance firm’s stock faces growth challenges – Investing.com, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.investing.com/news/swot-analysis/rlis-swot-analysis-insurance-firms-stock-faces-growth-challenges-93CH-4154865
19. RLI Corp. (RLI) SWOT Analysis – dcfmodeling.com, accessed August 28, 2025, https://dcfmodeling.com/products/rli-swot-analysis
20. RLI 2025 Company Profile: Stock Performance & Earnings – PitchBook, accessed August 28, 2025, https://pitchbook.com/profiles/company/10272-61
21. RLI Declares Regular Dividend | Morningstar, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.morningstar.com/news/business-wire/20250814706571/rli-declares-regular-dividend
22. Stock Info – Dividend History – RLI Corp – Investor relations, accessed August 28, 2025, https://investors.rlicorp.com/stock-info/dividend-history/default.aspx
23. RLI CORP. NOTICE OF 2025 ANNUAL MEETING AND PROXY …, accessed August 28, 2025, https://s204.q4cdn.com/949661285/files/doc_financials/2025/sr/2025-Proxy-Statement-03-24-2025.pdf
24. RLI CORP – SEC.gov, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/84246/000155837025003998/rli-20250513xdef14a.htm
25. RLI (RLI) P/E Ratio: Current & Historical Analysis, accessed August 28, 2025, https://public.com/stocks/rli/pe-ratio
26. RLI Price to Book Ratio 2010-2025 – Macrotrends, accessed August 28, 2025, https://macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/RLI/rli/price-book
27. RLI Stock Price Quote | Morningstar, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.morningstar.com/stocks/xnys/rli/quote
28. RLI (RLI) Competitors and Alternatives 2025 – MarketBeat, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.marketbeat.com/stocks/NYSE/RLI/competitors-and-alternatives/
29. ACGL – Arch Capital Group PE ratio, current and historical analysis – FullRatio, accessed August 28, 2025, https://fullratio.com/stocks/nasdaq-acgl/pe-ratio
30. KNSL – Kinsale Capital Group PE ratio, current and historical analysis – FullRatio, accessed August 28, 2025, https://fullratio.com/stocks/nasdaq-knsl/pe-ratio
31. Kinsale Capital Price/Book Ratio 2014-2025 | KNSL – Macrotrends, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/KNSL/kinsale-capital/price-book
32. WRB – Berkley W R PE ratio, current and historical analysis – FullRatio, accessed August 28, 2025, https://fullratio.com/stocks/nyse-wrb/pe-ratio
33. ACGL Stock Price Quote | Morningstar, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.morningstar.com/stocks/xnas/acgl/quote
34. Kinsale Capital Group Price to Book Value Analysis – YCharts, accessed August 28, 2025, https://ycharts.com/companies/KNSL/price_to_book_value
35. W. R. Berkley | WRB Stock Price, Company Overview & News – Forbes, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.forbes.com/companies/w-r-berkley/
36. Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. (KNSL) Dividend Date & History – Koyfin, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.koyfin.com/company/knsl/dividends/
37. W. R. Berkley Corporation (WRB) Dividend Date & History – Koyfin, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.koyfin.com/company/wrb/dividends/
38. Rli stock dividend history, payout ratio & dates – FullRatio, accessed August 28, 2025, https://fullratio.com/stocks/nyse-rli/dividend
39. RLI Corp. (RLI) Dividend Date & History – Koyfin, accessed August 28, 2025, https://www.koyfin.com/company/rli/dividends/